diving with broken rib

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

DiverRtNY

Registered
Messages
53
Reaction score
20
Location
McKinney, Texas
# of dives
100 - 199
This will probably get moved to the medical section but lots of eyes come here...
I'm heading to Bayahibe next week and I broke a rib last Saturday. Curious as to what to expect as far as pain and discomfort. I've broken ribs before so besides the current discomfort associated with the rib I was wondering if anyone else has dove with one...
Dave
 
This will probably get moved to the medical section but lots of eyes come here...
I'm heading to Bayahibe next week and I broke a rib last Saturday. Curious as to what to expect as far as pain and discomfort. I've broken ribs before so besides the current discomfort associated with the rib I was wondering if anyone else has dove with one...
Dave

I never have had a broken rib.But if I did I would not attempt to dive, its just not worth the risk and further injuring yourself. You want to give your body time to heal properly. Being under any depth could cause you severe pain and subsequently putting you in danger.

Post pone dive until your ribs are fully healed, is my advice.

Hey in the mean time you can still get your diving fix while being on Scuba Board!

Frank G
Z GEAR - Z Gear Dive Mounts
 
Serious? Never.
 
This will probably get moved to the medical section but lots of eyes come here...
I'm heading to Bayahibe next week and I broke a rib last Saturday. Curious as to what to expect as far as pain and discomfort. I've broken ribs before so besides the current discomfort associated with the rib I was wondering if anyone else has dove with one...
Dave
Frequently, the energy required to fracture a rib can also cause other injuries to the chest i.e. pulmonary contusion, pneumothorax etc. The intercostal blood vessels also are in close proximity laying next to ribs.
While it may be a simple rib fracture, what if it isnt.
A rapidly developing tension pneumothorax on arrival at the surface is not my idea of a good time.
IMHO, it isnt worth the risk and I wouldnt dive with you until you have a clean bill of health.
Cheers
 
As with so many things – it depends. Is it broken or cracked? How severely?

My experience: Exiting from the first dive of a week-long dive trip, in rough seas, I cracked a rib on the ladder. One of the other divers was a physician who very briefly examined me and said it wasn’t a break. So I tried diving and was fine. The most pain was riding in vehicles. Recall that the air in your lungs is equalized to ambient pressure.
 
I fell last Nov. and seriously bruised my ribs. Didn't consider diving 'til no pain. Can't imagine diving with broken ribs.
 
this was my thought exactly with the pressure gradient exerted against the atm pressure. Otherwise our chest would incave at 300 ft, broken or not. It's not a flail chest, just a simple break. Not displaced. Other than discomfort and pain, as you would get with any rib, being positional and bending the wrong way, my sense tells me it is not of a big concern. Flail chest with recent chest tubes would be a bit different.
 
I wouldn't. Don't care if it's a 40$, 4000$ or 400k$ trip, I simply wouldn't. The ocean will be there next time.
 
You are obviously suffering from what they call in general aviation "go fever." You are planning to do something under marginal conditions (see JFK Jr.) and you know you should just stay home, but you really, really want to go. You have asked the correct question, but despite what almost everyone is telling you, you're still saying "but it's only a broken rib."

Here are some good questions for you:

Do you have trip insurance? Most people get it these days and injury or illness is covered under most plans. If you have insurance, use it and go another time.

Is the possibility of a pulmonary contusion or pneumothorax an acceptable risk for you and or your family to take while on vacation?

The Dominican Republic is a place where proper medical personnel and facilities may be many miles/hours away. How far away is the nearest chamber? Do you have DAN insurance?

Have you called the DAN medline to ask a dive medicine expert if they think this is a good idea? I like SCUBAboard, but the right people to ask about this is your physician or at least DAN.

Look, we wouldn't be in this forum if we weren't all crazy about diving. But diving with a serious injury, especially an injury that could threaten the lungs is just plain crazy. Do yourself and your loved ones a favor and postpone your trip. Don't turn an annoying injury into a life threatening one.

Happy Diving!
 
IIRC you are at a greater risk of DCS with am unhealed fracture. Quite how big an additional risk, who knows?

Personally I would either check with DAN or a doctor with experience in diving and take their advice
 
https://www.shearwater.com/products/swift/

Back
Top Bottom