Dr. Lecter
Contributor
I'll take the blame for this. I originally wrote this for a group of professionals on Linkedin, many of whom complain incessantly about the state of the industry and how it's declined. We see it in the decline of attendance at the DEMA show which has been nicknamed by some the "travel, trinkets and training show". Frankly, the internet, including ScubaBoard has been blamed by many, including DEMA, for the general malaise of the industry.
It seems like there's a portion of the industry that's confusing the now-less-relevant middlemen with the industry as a whole. While I'm sure it's much less fun for dive pros who are used to there being enough fat in the middle to make for riproaring DEMAs, the reality is that the Brand<-$->Dealer-<$$$->Joe Blow model that once dominated is increasingly being challenged by divers who prefer to (1) buy gear online, and (2) buy from brands where they don't have to go to their LDS to get service/support.
You were demanding numbers for fauxstistics earlier: where's the evidence that there's be a decline in certifications QoverQ or YRoverYR since whatever date you'd like to set? Is non-commercial diving in decline, or, are an equal or greater number of participants just spending their money more efficiently? If it's the latter, I'm not sure that paying for someone's dive vacation so they can make some Youtube videos is really going to help the sport all that much.