How does Panglao / Balicasag compare with Cabilao for logistics and diving?
Panglao :
Beaches, lots of accoms choices hotels and people on the beaches, a mix of mediocre to very good restaurants. 15 mnutes from the International airport, 30 minutes from the Tagbilaran ferry..
Great diving on Balicasag with schools of jacks and cudas, loads of turtles, good coral coverage. Panglao/Alona is more small dropoffs, nudis and macro (froggies/GPF), there is aoccasionally a big school of sardines on the northern side of the island.
Dive centers also organize daytrips to Pamilacan : corals, seasnakes.
Cabilao :
Very few dive resorts (3?), no restaurants outside the resort. Very quiet island, 1h30 drive+short boatride from Panglao airport, 1hr from the Tagbilaran ferry port.
Once I had to cross the channel directly from Cabilao to Argao/Cebu on a bangka because a typhoon was coming and I didn't want to miss my flight back, however I don't think this type of transfer can be easily arranged, resorts would be reluctant.
Diving : western side deep walls with exceptional hard/soft coral, some of the best in the Visayas,many reef fish but fish schools are a less frequent sight. Decent macro : pygmy seahorses on the walls, algae inhabitants and froggies on Lighthouse reef also muck style macro on the other side (Shrimps, nudis...).