Welcome to the board Carey. I really don't know of a bad place in Bonaire, it's mainly depends on what you prefer. I do however have a couple of suggestions/comments. Where ever you stay, don't get an all-inclusive food package. There are way too many places on Bonaire to eat to lock yourself down to one place or resort. A breakfast is fine but otherwise skip the meal packages. Also, at least until you get here and dive a day or 2 drop the boat packages. Most of us never used all the dives we had in our packages and never get them after the first trip. You can always add them back once on island or if you like add just a few during your stay, dropping them will save you $120+ per diver. When comparing packages, be sure to compare apples to apples. Some packages include an airport transfer, some do not. Some include a truck ( and you will want a truck- don't get a car or RAV4 type vehicle) and some don't. Then there is resort size. The Plaza is pretty big, esp by Bonaire standards while Den Lamen is very small, Buddy, Sand Dollar and Capt Dons are somewhere in the middle. By the way, Sand Dollar has some nice little efficiencies that are reasonable. As for dive shops, I don't know of a bad one but I do tend to prefer the use the one associated with the resort I am staying at, it just makes things easier.