I'm looking at buying a rebreather for the first time myself. I'm advanced certified, rescue certified, and have over 100 logged dives from 0 visability to 100'plus, tropical water to artic.
Ive been laboring over the decision of SCR or CCR new or used.
I finally got to spend some time talking to two navy seals about rebreathers, both are now commercial divers. They recommended I start out with a SCR and move to CCR later. I could always sell my SCR and get a good price for it then spend more money later for the CCR.
The recomendation to start on SCR was based on the fact you will be innundated with procedures that if you fail to follow can kill you. I wanted a CCR to start with and felt I could handle the responsibilities (I have always been a competent diver). Ive been reading though over the last two weeks of goofs rebreather users comonly encounter and I was surprised at how often and how silly many of them are. (Forgeting to turn the unit on). The new skills required to dive a CCR do not even cover the Deco stop skills and procedures that you will need to develop for staged deco. If you think you'll buy a CCR and never dive deep, I would say your lying to yourself. Doing such a thing without nailed down procedures really puts yourself at risk.
Most CCR's that would be worth buying are computer controled, I ve read that it is really important as a beginner to learn how to dive the CCR manually and not with the computer, this helps you devlope bail out skills to save your life. Its a personal opinion of mine that starting out with the computer control will cause you to lean on the control and fail to develop the needed skills to master the CCR, not so much because you would not try to develop the needed skills but because you will be so overcome with new diving situations that the electronic control will become a crutch to true mastery of the rebreather.
There is also the issue of price. I have yet to see a Halcyon RB80 or Inspiration used (i know they exist) and new I have seen them with training run for about $7000. A SCR like the Drager Dolphin runs about $3500 new with $500 for training.
This does not include the cost of a computer. I'm looking at the Alladin with O2 sensor about $2000. (it can also be used on OC Nitrox) and the OMS VR3 about $1300 with o2 sensor (based on my understanding can be upgraded via pin you pay for but can only work as CCR, SCR, or OC at any one time)
I personally am going to buy a used Drager Dolphin Rebreather from an Instructor (if I like the discovery dive) I would recomend that if you buy used you do it this way. I have heard several stories where a rebreather was bought on ebay or used and took in for training, the rebreather was not fit to dive and had to be re-built. The person could have bought a brand new rebreather for what he ended up paying for the used unit with repairs.
I'm also getting a deal on training, my Nitrox and Advanced Nitrox classes are being included for free and my Rebreather class is being discounted to $300, rebreather is $2500. I plan on training with the rebreather and paying in sections so that if there are any problems during training I will require them to be repaired before final payment, (it has already been rebuilt so I doubt I will have any problems)
I decided to go SCR and upgrade later to CCR. I can get comfortable mastering my rebreather skills while at the same time use the unit to develop Deco skills, deep diving skills, bailout processes. Not to metion checklists and processes to make sure the SCR is set up properly before a dive. I am told that the SCR is more forgiving than CCR for newbies.
If you decide to buy used find a dealer that will sell you a used model and throw in instruction, get several price quotes from several dealers and bargain between them (you may have to travel for the training, I was prepaired to go to miami until I found a local shop) This way you should be able to ensure the quality of the unit and get a better price.
Here is a link to an article that helped me change my mind from starting out with the CCR and instead buying the SCR first. Its only one of many but this article detailed some of the procedures you need to follow. I'm a solid diver the only thind I ever forget is to start my dive timer, if I forget to turn on my CCR I could die.
http://www.metacut.com/rebreathers/RichPyleArticle_1.htm#Search Query Form
Take a discovery dive, buy a SCR master the skills needed, get deep training then either sell your SCR or keep it, then buy the CCR. Or dont