Thoughts for instructors from a newbie

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

jstuart1

Contributor
Messages
364
Reaction score
2
I complete my OW dives this weekend so of course that means I am newer than new at this. One thing I would like to comment on based on my experience thus far regarding skills involves paying attention to the spg. Personally I think that since frequently checking the spg is the primary means for avoiding an OOA situation, that from the very first CW you should be taught to check the gauge frequently and required to do so. If you do this all through CW and OW it will help develop the habit of doing so when you are out diving once certified. I don't know how other instructors handle this and I'm definitly not bashing mine, I just think its something that should be done.

I also think more time should be spent on handling and transporting tanks safely. Working in the chemical industry, safety around HP tanks has been ingraned in me from the getgo. I didn't think enough time was spent in class covering handling tanks safely for someone who has never been around them. There are some really impressive videos showing what happens when the valve gets knocked off a tank etc. Really drives the point home.

As for diving skills, I am treating my OW course as a permit to get tanks filled so I can practice skills I learned (obviously not truely mastered) in class. It also allows me to confirm I enjoy the sport and decide where to go from there. The person who compared it to a learners permit I agree with wholeheartedly.

You have to practice some skills with someone to critque you to really get it right. For example in the CW classes, I have not learned (figured out) how to "feel" where I am in the water. Meaning that I couldn't tell my tank was actually out of the water when swimming the pool. Its a 4-7' pool. I don't know how close to the bottom I should be without actually touching it.

One thing I am definitly figuring out from this board is that everything should be done slow and easy under water. Beginners are always nervous and will tend to hury to get through the skill. A class that is on a fast track would seem to encourage this hurry up mistake we make. Our pool sessions were once a week for about 2 hours so that didn't feel rushed. But you're under water and the instructor points from student to student to do the skill it leads to a rushed feeling. I have adoped using the stop signal to slow things down for the mask clearing which i have had problems with. The point I am trying to make here is that if instructors helped ingrane "slow and easy" from the getgo I think it would help students learn and perform skills better.

Just some thoughts from a newby who doesn't know much yet.

Judy
 
Great observations, Judy! Sounds like you've got what it takes to get the most out of our sport.

Where is Crosby? If you're anywhere near South Florida, I'd like to extend the invitation to dive with the Florida Conch Divers - we love diving with new friends, and most, if not all, of our divers follow the same sort of philosophy (usually stumbled upon with experience) that you've espoused so early in your diving career. All I can say is that I become more and more safe with every dive, and have really come to respect the slow and easy style of diving that I practice now.

You can find the Florida Conchs forum under Scubaboard clubs.

Welcome to the Board and to the sport.

Best wishes and safe ascents,
Grier
 
Crosby is in Texas near Houston. Being female I was a bit leary to put my full location in my profile but I should have probably put Houston rather than Crosby. I did post to the Florida Conchs as I am thinking about going to the Pensacola area the week of August 22. At some point I would like to go to south fla but since this would be a driving trip I think I'll stick to about 10-12 hours out. The Conchs in the area gave me some good places to dive for a newbie and a couple of invitations which I appreciate. I look forward to meeting some of the South Fla Conchs at some point in the not to distant future.

Judy
 
Nice post. I too am a newbie without any real dives under my belt. I feel much as you do. I now can go on professionally escorted dives or dive shallow waters to work on my technique and get used to my gear. Wish I didn't suck so much air.

I have to say my instructor was AWESOME. The whole class was very relaxed, and we drilled over and over. On our first dive someone kicked my regulator out of my mouth. I just slowly exhaled, found it and put it back in, no biggie.

I don't know how the other classes do it, but with my SSI class we did two nights a week for 3 weeks, then two days in the ocean. There is the Open Water book, which isn't super detailed but goes through the basics pretty well. You are supposed to have studied the book at home before the first class starts. The book did go into safely handling your tank and how to load it in the car, as did the accompanying video. The instructor talked more about VIC and hydro testing.

They HIGHLY recommended the Advanced Open Water class. I don't think they push it for the revenue (though I think some of the SSI courses are a big bogus). They really know that with a few hours of study, a few hours of pool and a few hours of ocean that you really aren't a "diver".

My thoughts,

Mark
 
Hey Judy,

Really good post. ;)

I wish some of my students were as sensible as you!

Where I teach, we don't go the fast track route either. It's one pool session a week for a couple hours, over 4 weeks and in my opinion i feel it makes better divers.

Regarding being taught how to feel where you are in the water...that all comes with experience. Your buoyancy and familiarity of equipment is a skill that gets better with each dive. You sound like you're gonna enjoy it :)

Scuba_freak
 
jstuart1:
I complete my OW dives this weekend so of course that means I am newer than new at this. One thing I would like to comment on based on my experience thus far regarding skills involves paying attention to the spg. Personally I think that since frequently checking the spg is the primary means for avoiding an OOA situation, that from the very first CW you should be taught to check the gauge frequently and required to do so. If you do this all through CW and OW it will help develop the habit of doing so when you are out diving once certified. I don't know how other instructors handle this and I'm definitly not bashing mine, I just think its something that should be done.

I also think more time should be spent on handling and transporting tanks safely. Working in the chemical industry, safety around HP tanks has been ingraned in me from the getgo. I didn't think enough time was spent in class covering handling tanks safely for someone who has never been around them. There are some really impressive videos showing what happens when the valve gets knocked off a tank etc. Really drives the point home.

As for diving skills, I am treating my OW course as a permit to get tanks filled so I can practice skills I learned (obviously not truely mastered) in class. It also allows me to confirm I enjoy the sport and decide where to go from there. The person who compared it to a learners permit I agree with wholeheartedly.

You have to practice some skills with someone to critque you to really get it right. For example in the CW classes, I have not learned (figured out) how to "feel" where I am in the water. Meaning that I couldn't tell my tank was actually out of the water when swimming the pool. Its a 4-7' pool. I don't know how close to the bottom I should be without actually touching it.

One thing I am definitly figuring out from this board is that everything should be done slow and easy under water. Beginners are always nervous and will tend to hury to get through the skill. A class that is on a fast track would seem to encourage this hurry up mistake we make. Our pool sessions were once a week for about 2 hours so that didn't feel rushed. But you're under water and the instructor points from student to student to do the skill it leads to a rushed feeling. I have adoped using the stop signal to slow things down for the mask clearing which i have had problems with. The point I am trying to make here is that if instructors helped ingrane "slow and easy" from the getgo I think it would help students learn and perform skills better.

Just some thoughts from a newby who doesn't know much yet.

Hi Judy,

Welcome to scuba! You're hooked now... brahahahah! :devil:

Many of the points you bring up are actually included by most instructions I know. For example, we really stress that tanks should not be left standing unattended and/or should be laid down at all times. Usually someone who forgets is given a "beer penalty" as in "hey, you left that tank standing & walked away from it, so you now owe the everyone in the class a beer".

No offense to your Instructor, but what you had on your list is usually drilled into students from the start. It just sounds like your teacher wasn't quite as assertive about it as they could have been.

DSDO,
 
Judy, you got it. Take your time, listen and learn, practice, practice, practice, and just enjoy. The "Stop, think, then act" approach will serve you well. Dive Safe!
 
Judy,
Good post. If my student leave a tank standing, unattended, it "mysteriously" disappears.
Tim
 

Back
Top Bottom