Spearfishing Licensing

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

Messages
2
Reaction score
0
Location
Australia
# of dives
25 - 49
does anybody else agree that in victoria a RFL is not enough for a person to go out and spear fish. Spearfishermen should have to compee training to recieve a license to be able to go spearfishing. this way it would be possible to avoid accidents such as being shot by a spear, fish that are illegal to catch being caught.
does anybody else agree??
 
No, I don't agree. A spearfisherman should be capable of identifying the fish which is being targeted. A formal certification class is not required to accomplish this. Time in the water looking at fish and learning to ID them is what is required.

Shooting other divers? That's basic gun safety. Is that a problem there?
 
there is a problem with the gun safety, there have been incidences where a person has been shot in the back by the spear, i personally know people taht have been scuba diving and instructing a class that almost got hit by a spear.
just by spending time in the water with the fish does not mean that u suddenly learn what fish is illegal to catch and what is not. ive been diving for a couple of years now and i cant identify most of the fish i see myself.
 
No:angrymob:NO! Stop the madness!!:shocked2: Leave the fish costume home!:goldfish:
 
well, Lucy has a point: If we need a certification for doing almost anything, why not for spearing? Then we will all feel so safe and content: surely a person after one hour in class and $150 for the cert. will be safe to us and the environment. ;) And if not... Force majeure!
 
How about taking responsibility for personal actions instead of requiring a special licence? If you shoot someone with a spear, you should be subject to the same penalties you would be if you shot them with a bullet. If you spear an illegal fish, it should be no different than if you shot or landed any other protected species. If you want to spearfish, it's your responsibility to know what you're shooting at. If you aren't certain your target is a legal, don't shoot it.
 
there is a problem with the gun safety, there have been incidences where a person has been shot in the back by the spear, i personally know people taht have been scuba diving and instructing a class that almost got hit by a spear.
just by spending time in the water with the fish does not mean that u suddenly learn what fish is illegal to catch and what is not. ive been diving for a couple of years now and i cant identify most of the fish i see myself.

Ah, lucy_goosey, you're taking away needed income for your wildlife department. Wildlife enforcement officers in Oklahoma check for illegal catch. If you possess an illegal fish, you pay a big fine and donate all your dive gear, maybe your boat, and maybe the vehicle you pulled the boat with (depends how many fish you've taken). And to make sure you understand your offense. . . go directly to jail, until you've bailed out. Most spearfishermen in our area get the message before they hunt.

When fish are being hunted by new divers, they thoughtfully keep their distance. When a new diver sees a fish they can hunt, they focus, or look straight at the fish and that tips off the fish its being hunted. Two beginning divers won't get in range of each other because of this reaction. Us old, moldy divers can usually get much closer, and we can tell by the reaction of the fish, if there is another diver anywhere nearby.

I've been around spearfishermen for 40 years, with many contests with over 200 competitors, and never heard of a diver being speared by another. A couple of divers have handled their own guns, and shot themselves.

You see a problem and want to help make spearfishing safer. . . that's good but unless you have a particularly foolish group of new divers, it's not as risky as an outsider might perceive.
 
... Spearfishermen should have to compee training to recieve a license to be able to go spearfishing...

You should probably spend several hours reading this board. It has some very valuable information that would have answered your question.

I disagree that a spearfisherman needs a license.
 
I disagree very strongly with this. I spear all the time and have never heard of someone shooting another diver. I have seen a boat shot and someone shoot them self when firing a gun out of water (dumb a$$). I don't have an issue paying the $6 a year for my license but you want me to go sit through a class to tell me how to spearfish safely, forget it. If I feel someone is not safe spearing around me they will find out real quick.
 

Back
Top Bottom