Spear fishing question

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

TheHuth

Contributor
Messages
334
Reaction score
88
Location
Long Beach, CA
# of dives
50 - 99
It occurred to me that there are many people who spearfish, and I may run in to them from time to time. What is the protocol for non spear fishing divers in proximity to spear fishing divers?

Spear fishing is something I have absolutely no interest in. I'm mostly concerned about my own safety. Is it common for spear fishing divers to dive with no spear fishing divers? If yes, how does that usually work?
 
Generally speaking, the spearos disappear as soon as they hit the water. I've only been on two boats that had any spearfishers on them and it was not a problem at all.

Newer spearfishers may be a little less diligent about where they point their spears, which warrants a talking to, but most are very conscientious about the fact that not all people are interested in or even approve of spearfishing. As a result they tend to be fairly "quiet" about it on mixed boats.
 
I've been on a boat maybe a couple of times with spearos--think both times it was the DM. Never saw them during the dive, though I must admit I did think about it a little.
 
Last edited:
Have been on boats with spearos several times. They splash first. Divers scare fish so they go off by themselves. Only problem has been when they shoot a big cobia and its lonely remora tries to attach during your safety stop
 
As stated previously, the spearos usually are dropped 1st and away from the 'sightseers'. I do both and if I've don't got a gun, I don't and won't to be around one who is actively hunting. It goes both ways - I don't want other divers around if i'm hunting as it spooks the fish. This time of year, the lemons are in and spearing anything will get lots of attention even if it's just a lionfish on a polespear.
 
It occurred to me that there are many people who spearfish, and I may run in to them from time to time. What is the protocol for non spear fishing divers in proximity to spear fishing divers?

Spear fishing is something I have absolutely no interest in. I'm mostly concerned about my own safety. Is it common for spear fishing divers to dive with no spear fishing divers? If yes, how does that usually work?
That's a good question. I dive with spearos all the time, as I spearfish myself probably 90% or more of the time I'm in salt water. But, I know the divers I dive with and they know how to act on the boat and in the water.

In most cases, the spearos will steer clear of other divers on a charter, so you'll likely never see them. There are a couple of behaviors that you can easily to identify that let you know that you have a novice spearo.

1. Diver loads the speargun on the boat. By loading, I mean pulling back the bands on a bandgun (spear in barrel is OK), or inserting the spear in the case of a pneumatic. This is generally frowned upon, and something that should be brought to the captain's attention right away.

2. Diver hands up a loaded speargun at the end of dive. (See #1 for definition of loaded.) This is a big issue, and very dangerous. Notify captain right away.

3. Diver hands speargun up at the end of dive with spear pointed up. This one is not as severe, but the vast majority of spearos recommend handing gun up butt first. With the butt first method, the guy on the boat is not at risk of getting poked due to wave action.

If you see these behaviors (esp 1 & 2) you have very good reason to believe you have a very inexperienced spearfisher on the boat. Use caution around these divers, and bring the transgressions up to the crew if they don't address them right away.

During the dive, the loaded speargun should never be pointed toward any divers. Chances are, the spearos will keep their distance, so you likely may never see them during the dive.
 

Back
Top Bottom