Not enough practice ditching weights.
Sometimes instruction puts more emphasis on removing gear than on ditching weights. Victims sometimes ditch their regulator, BC and tank instead of their weight belt. You and your buddy should understand how your gear works and stay current on your basic skills. If diving with a weight belt, it is a good idea to carry a spare buckle in your "Save a dive" kit. The dive community standardized weight belts as a right handed release with all other releases being left handed. Even if a diver drops their weights and is on the surface, they might not be showing signs of panic. It is important to make sure their BC is inflated, or they may silently slip below the surface and drown.
Before each dive
1) Attach your weight belt the same way for each dive
2) Gear up as if you are going to ditch weights on every dive
3) Ensure your weights will not catch on your gear, i.e. BC, lights, retractors, etc
4) Practice finding the weight belt release
5) Mentally rehearse emergency ascent procedures
6) Check your and your buddy's weights and buckles for a pre-dive check, find out how
his/her gear works
7) Watch out for "the other guy"
If you cannot get to the surface by inflating your BC or swimming
1) First try to solve the problem underwater
2) Ensure your weight drop zone is clear
3) Ditch your weights
4) Look up, relax, and exhale continuously
5) During your ascent flare your body the last 20 feet to reduce the risk of an embolism
Most common problems
1) Buckle not holding = the belt comes loose unexpectedly
2) Broken buckle or misaligned weight belt.
3) If the above happens, this is followed by a hazardous, uncontrolled ascent
Diver Alert Network
DAN collected data on 418 diving fatalities for 1998-2002; information regarding the removal of the weight belt or integrated weights is known in 285 (68%) cases. Of those 285 fatalities, the diver or someone rendering assistance removed the weights in only 43 (15%) cases. A small percentage of divers suffered a sudden, incapacitating cardiac event. However, based on the circumstances surrounding the accident, the majority of divers had time to remove the weights.
CONCLUSIONS: In the vast majority of fatal recreational diving accidents the weight belt or integrated weights are still in place when the diver is removed from the water. Despite training to the contrary, the diver rarely ditches the weights, nor do those who render assistance to the stricken diver. Contributing factors likely include panic as well as inadequate training and practice of emergency procedures