The last 6 years we have purchased at least two masks from Seavision and probably 3 different sets of lenses. As mentioned in my previous post, this is the first time we have NOT used toothpaste on the lenses... you read the "results". Unsatisfactory!
If the lenses ARE getting scratched from the toothpaste (which is used only a few times a year) neither of us can notice the difference. And I've been wearing glasses all my life; I'd find scratches in a flash.
I believe the key is to only use your fingertips when applying the toothpaste. The action should be gentle, not like scrubbing a pan with a brillo pad. After rinsing, the lenses (even the acrylic ones) should feel "squeeky clean" to the touch. If not, repeat the process.
FWIW,