Opinions

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

Kharon

Contributor
Messages
4,303
Reaction score
4,371
Location
Upstate NY
# of dives
200 - 499
Talking about reliability statistics - anyone have feelings on Poseidon 2nd stages. I've pretty much decided to toss the Hollis 500SE and go back to my Cressi XS2. I wanted a side exhaust and plugged the right side escape vents with marine goop on the Cressi. It worked fine. Then I got the Hollis and it worked wonderfully - for a time. Then it crapped the bed on my Bonaire trip. I don't want more problems. I can service the Cressi. Would a Poseidon be totally reliable? I've heard they are a PITA about IP pressure. I don't want a reg I have to eff around with like a Fiat every time I start up.
 
Nothing will be "totally reliable" especially for someone who is pretty much critical of everything , as you are. Just sayin'.
 
Poseidon regs are extremely reliable. There is a ton of misinformation floating around about them. The “high IP” only relates to the cyklon regs. Both the Jetstream and Xstream regs operate very well around a typical 125-135 IP.

They are also some of the easiest regs out there to find service parts for.
 
I use Poseidon Jetstreams almost exclusively. Once they are set, they will go years without needing anything.
Now, the problem is getting them set properly.
What is important to remember is that these are unbalanced, non-adjustable, upstream second stages. What this means is that when you tune them to the bitter edge, it is CRITICAL that the IP is set properly as even a 1psi difference is enough to cause it to leak.

With the 3960 first stage as seen with most Jetstreams, the balancing is not all that great and it is inversely proportional to the supply pressure. Since it is inversely proportional, when they say you need to hook the first stage up to a high pressure supply bottle when servicing, they aren't kidding. Upstream valves need to be set at the minimum IP they will see during service.
The IP swing on the 3960 from 4000psi down to 300psi is about 20psi so it is not insignificant. I have done some field adjustments of first stages where the supply was only about 3100-3200psi, and when that first stage went on a cave filled bottle around 3800psi, the second stage was leaking as the IP was too low. I try to set the IP at 4000psi and tune the second stages at the 4000psi supply with an IP of 120-125. The IP will go up as the tank pressure goes down, so the regs won't freeflow until tank pressure is below about 200psi. When they do that, you finish an inhale and they'll give a light bubble before locking up. That's a great indicator on a stage bottle that it's time to switch and what I use when cave diving instead of checking spg's, neat little trick.

While the above is the protocol for the Xstreams and Jetstreams which use an unbalanced-upstream valve, the Cyklon is an unbalanced-downstream valve. With a downstream valve, you need to adjust the IP at the maximum IP, so the first stage IP adjustment, and second stage cracking adjustment need to be done at minimum supply pressure when using a Cyklon vs. maximum supply pressure with the Jetstream/Xstream

That initial setup is a lot more finicky than say a Scubapro G250 where you put the adjustment tool on there, turn the knob all the way out, turn until it hisses a little bit and back it off. That said, once it's done, you don't have to do anything for several years and they don't just randomly go out of adjustment
 
And is a 1st that will hold its IP.

The Poseidon first stages all hold their IP very well, and for a very long time due to the unique bullet or sphere design vs. a hard crown that cuts a groove into the seats. The important part is how well they are balanced and adjusting the second stage cracking efforts at the right point in the IP balance.
 
Those were some of the issues I was curious about the potential setup with having a non-Poseidon 1st Stage. (Frankenregulator)
 
And is a 1st that will hold its IP.

And acccording to ad claims by Poseidon re. the paired 1st stage, the IP changes due to depth and gas density so the 2nd stage should be immune to IP deviance.
 
https://www.shearwater.com/products/perdix-ai/

Back
Top Bottom