My GF, Adm. Linda shoots a D40 in an Aquatica housing and wins contests.
1. Check total cost of ownership. Adm. Linda found that an Aquatica housing
was cheaper than Ikelite because she didn't have to buy synch cords. I had
a bunch of Nikon single synch cords (and I suspect they are cheap on e-bay)
2. For macro, the 60 mm would be the first choice lens.
3. If you dive Melbourne, the 18-whatever isn't wide enough. Melbourne
is a lot like Monterey vis-wis, so you need to get REALLY close. For
wide-angle in Monterey, I shoot the RS 13 mm and get RIGHT UP THERE.
That's on a full-frame sensor.. Your 18-whatever would be a 27-whatever.
I know several people that are happy with the Sigma 10-whatever.
When you've made your lens and housing manufacturer(s) decisions, get
back with us to make sure you have all the right stuff.