Nikon Coolpix 4600 vs Sealife Reefmaster.

[Banshee Ben]

I have had the Sealife with strobe for a couple years now and rarly get a picture worth keeping other than for memory sake. I got the Nikon coolpix 4600 for my b-day and was looking into getting a underwater case for it. Not knowing much about underwater photography, and not jumping at the $240 case deal, I was wanting other opinions on which one to use for scuba? Looking at other peoples pics it seems the digital cameras are taking better pictures.