Need help with deciding on a new set-up

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

sharonhaz

New
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
I currently have a canon G10 in the canon housing using a sea life strobe. The strobe has given me quite a bit of trouble: the company "fixed" it once and then replaced it. I did an Aggressor trip in the Caymans and the "Certificate of Accomplishment" I received at the end of the trip was for "Strobe Mechanic."

Keep in mind I am trying to be conservative price-wise because I only get to dive about once a year (twice if I'm, lucky). The other important basic info is I spend most of my picture taking on macro or close-up pics.

CAMERA: So my first goal was to get a new strobe. However, since I thought it would be a good idea to have a back-up camera for my next live-aboard so I have a "spare" camera, my buddy suggested I get a used G10. However in looking at the used prices it looks like I would have to spend $200-$250. So I thought, maybe it would be better to get a G15 for $200 more.

HOUSING: And since the canon housings don't allow access to the dial (even though I know there is a way to do it per other posters on this site by manipulating some of the buttons) I thought getting the new G15 Fantasea housing would be best for accessing all the controls. Then everyone says that Ikelite is the best housing (in the lower price range) so I started looking at that option. Does the Ikelite housing give access to ALL the canon buttons and DIAL? Is it too bulky?

STROBES: In looking at all the compatibility info for strobes for the Fantasea housing I got really confused. I tried to call Fantasea to ask them questions about strobes, but they don't have a 800 # and are in Canada. For the Ikelite, the least expensive TTL strobe is the DS 51 - the DS 160 is almost a $1000 - I can't justify that. But the DS 51 doesn't work with the canon in manual mode. Does that mean if I use manual camera mode I CAN use the DS 51 manually as well? Is there a better strobe that will sync with the housing directly like the DS 51?

STROBE ARM: I know the SA arm systems would allow a lot of flexibility, but I don't like the idea of messing with the different joints so I am tending towards the flex arm - am I missing something?

So....canon G15, Ikelite 6146.15 housing, DS51 strobe, and Ikelite Flex arm ??????

Last question: if I decide this is the best set up I saw the "Canon G15 Underwater Housing 6146.15 & DS51 Strobe Package by Ikelite" listed for $1175 on ebay sold by shootunderwater - I have a 10% off coupon for ebay (which I think will apply) - is that a good company to buy from? or is it better to go with B&H? Anybody else who's cheaper AND reliable?

Thanks - I know this is a lot!
 

Back
Top Bottom