Trip Report Narayana - Tubbataha LOB, 15-21 June 2025

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

sostil

Registered
Messages
24
Reaction score
65
Location
USA
# of dives
100 - 199
Background: My boyfriend (BF) and I are budget-backpacking-scuba diving SEA for the next ~8 months. Our goal is to see as much healthy hard coral in the Coral Triangle as possible. We brought all our own gear (excluding weights & tanks of course), including full 3mm wetsuits, which we carry in 75L backpacks. The prices listed are for two people, unless otherwise noted. Apologies if the report is too long!

Day 0: We had flown in from Coron (layover in Cebu) two days earlier due to more cancelled ferries and a last minute schedule change.

Through communication with the Narayana manager, Diane, it was confirmed that we would be picked up via van from our accommodation in Puerto Princesa and brought to the meeting point (Lato Restaurant) at 13:45-14:00.

We got a message asking if we were ready for pickup around 10:00 since they were there to pickup some other guests from the same accommodation. We were not, since we were expecting the later time, and the later time was once again confirmed. Checkout was at 12:00 so BF and I killed time in a nearby cafe (which I updated Diane with). Around 13:00 a guy in a Narayana shirt walked in and asked us if we were a part of the liveaboard, which caught us off guard. We agreed to leave earlier and they loaded our bags into the van and dropped us off at SM Mall, stating that they would pick us up around 13:45-14:00. After pickup from the mall, us and two other guests were dropped off at the Lato Restaurant to wait for the other guests to be dropped off.

This pickup sequence wasn’t difficult, just unnecessarily complicated/changed multiple times day-of.

Once everyone else (16 guests in total, including BF & I) got to the restaurant, Diane handled the collection of everyone’s park & environment fees in cash (5000 PHP & 200 PHP per person, respectively). One note about this was that you had the option to pay in PHP or in USD, and the USD option was NOT equivalent to the PHP… (ex: park fee was 5000 PHP or 100 USD, which is ~5600 PHP). Wifi was also paid for at this time (1100 PHP or 20 USD, which was an ok conversion (~1126P)). Wifi was per person, per device, for the entire week, and only available in the common dining area.

Our bigger bags that we left in the van were transported directly to the boat into our rooms. Around 15:00 we were transported to the Narayana via dinghy directly from the front of the restaurant, which is on the harbor. Narayana only had one dinghy so we made the trip in two groups.

The two groups we made the trip to the Narayana in were our dive groups for the trip, since the other group consisted of 10 divers that came together. The other 6 of us were in the other group.

The Narayana: The boat was not bad at all, considering that it was one of the cheapest options for Tubbataha. Considering our Apo Reef adventure, this boat was luxury, but it will not win any competitions against the big name LOBs.

The boat has 3 decks. The bottom deck consists of the dive deck, which leads directly into a hallway with 6 cabins. The dive deck is small and crammed, with space for everyone’s (16 people) tanks to have their own assigned location but you were definitely squished into your neighbors. Since there was one dinghy anyway, the two groups got geared up separately, which allowed us to spread out on the dive deck a bit as compensation.

The boat has a compressor onboard and they would fill your tank between dives, rather than switching tanks out.

The second deck was the main deck area and consisted of an open-air dining/lounging area. This was also the wifi area and where we received briefings. There were two “walkways” along the side of the boat leading to the bow, which passed 2 additional cabins (1 on each side).

The crew told us that these cabins were traditionally for Diane and the owner, Frank. They were not coming along this trip since it was fully booked (normally only 14 guests). We were lucky because we had one of these cabins and the wifi extended from the dining area to reach (albeit only 1 bar).

I can’t speak on the other rooms downstairs but our room was quite nice, with a full-size bed and some shelves. The room had a smoke detector inside but I forgot to ask the last time it was tested so unsure if it was solely cosmetic or not (I am a cynic). The attached bathroom was a fully wet bathroom. It also smelled like the cleaning solution in a urinal/porta potty which was awful. The smell didn’t come into the room though. We had outlets in the room near the shelving and received no advisories about not keeping devices plugged in for long which I took as a good sign.

The third and top deck consisted of just a little sunbed/lounge.

The food on-board was okay. I didn’t feel blown away but it wasn’t inedible. There was always coffee, tea, hot chocolate, and cold/hot drinking water available at any time. In addition, you could have a glass of wine/can of beer at the end of the day for an additional charge.

After coming on-board and seeing our rooms, Frank gave us all a boat briefing. He was definitely a character and honestly quite racist and off-putting.

After every few minutes he would pause and point to a random person of the 10 diver group (who were Chinese) and ask them if they understood English. He also mixed up two divers (who didn’t look similar at all) just because they were sitting next to each other and Asian (but different nationalities). He even complemented one diver for speaking English well “for a Chinese”, when the diver said they weren’t Chinese, but Korean.

After the boat briefing we assembled our gear downstairs on the dive deck while the coast guard checked the boat. There were hangers for our wetsuits and a shelf underneath the tanks to leave masks/boots/weights. The fins were secured underneath weights as well.

The boat ended up leaving around 16:00 with calm waters (which was lucky! because the trips the week before were cancelled due to the monsoon). After dinner (early, ~17:00) we chatted a bit with the DMs (Edu & Job) and then had an early bedtime.

Day 1: Allegedly there was supposed to be a wake-up call at 5:40 for a 5:50 briefing, but we didn’t hear one. Good thing we set phone alarms for 5:30!

The first dive of the day was the check dive. We were supposed to only do the first two dives at the same site and then move to be closer to the ranger station, but due to waves we stayed at the same site all day, which got old after the first dive and was even more boring the third and then fourth dive. It was very disappointing that we essentially wasted a full day on the check dive site…

The visibility was really good the entire day, min 35m/100ft.

The dive operation: Mostly competent/good. I was irritated because there were not enough weight options available and therefore had to dive either unbalanced or overweighted (no weight belt but weight pockets on the top tank band). I chose to be overweighted after 2 dives of being unbalanced because it was such a pain.

The days consisted of a 5:50 briefing with the goal to start the first dive at 6:00. We then had a long SI with breakfast and the second dive briefing around 9:30 with the second dive at 9:40. Another long SI with lunch, third briefing at 12:50, and third dive at 13:00. SI with snacks, fourth briefing at 15:50, and fourth dive at 16:00. Dinner was around 19:00.

The dives went 50-60mins and low air was considered 50/60 bar (~700-750 PSI).

Edu did all of the briefings. He wasn’t our guide (with the other group) but was very knowledgeable and had been working on the Narayana for several years.

Job was a new DM for the Narayana since his predecessor had a family emergency and couldn’t participate on this trip.

Dive 1: Malayan Wreck/Reef
Max depth 81ft, 64 mins, min water temp 84F.
We saw 10+ sharks and many bumpbhead parrotfish.

Dive 2: Malayan Reef
Max depth 86ft, 55 mins, min water temp 84F.
No sharks.

Dive 3: Malayan Reef
Max depth 69ft, 57 mins, min water temp 84F.
We saw 3 separate adult Napoleon wrasses and 10+ sharks.

Dive 4: Malayan Reef
Max depth 63ft, 63 mins, min water temp 84F.
We saw 2 more adult Napoleon wrasses and a huge school of jacks at the safety stop.

Very uneventful day except for the boring repetitive sites. After dinner, Edu announced that we’d already used up 7,000/14,000 L of the freshwater!!! BF & I were quite perplexed and suspect that some people didn’t use the shower in bursts, instead keeping it on the entire time…

//Break for character limit
 
Day 2: We finally moved to a different mooring around 4:00.

Dive 1: Bird Islet
Max depth 95ft, 64 mins, min water temp 83F.
Extremely disheartening dive. Where we dropped in had the most beautiful corals, comparable to South End at Apo Reef, but with immense fish life (5+ sharks and lots of schooling fish!). Unfortunately we only stayed there for ~5 mins before descending. The rest of the dive was a whole bunch of looking at nothing, just sand and rocks. The ascent/safety stop corals were heavily impacted by dynamite fishing and nothing like the healthy ones at the descent. Very depressing dive.

Dive 2: Washing Machine
Max depth 98ft, 63 mins, min water temp 83F.
Contrary to the name, there was barely any current. Dropped down and immediately saw 2 full-grown Napoleon wrasses and then 2 white tip sharks sitting on the sand being cleaned. A blue spotted stingray popped up afterwards which wrapped up the action. We then spent the other ~50mins drifting slowly on the wall looking at nothing. Once we ascended, there was only coral rubble from bleaching. It seemingly ran on forever and was depressing.

Dive 3: Washing Machine
Max depth 63ft, 63 mins, min water temp 84F.
The first half of this dive was quite exciting as we dropped down to a strong current. We also saw 30+ sharks (NOT an exaggeration). We saw 3 separate schools of 8,6, and 7 white tips respectively, and then many solo sharks preying on top of the reef. The second half of the dive was disappointing again. We ended up doing two slow laps of the same rubble area, which is probably the most dead coral we’ve seen so far in the Philippines.

Dive 4: Shark Airport
Max depth 62ft, 60 mins, min water temp 84F.
Ironically not as many sharks as Dive 3 (saw maybe ~5). The topography of the wall with many overhangs was cool. After we crested the top there was a lot of beautiful healthy coral but it soon faded to the destroyed patches AGAIN. I cannot stress enough the decline of Tubbataha’s hard corals.

While eating dinner, the boat moved to the south atoll in preparation for the next day of diving. This day we only used 1,000 L & had 6,000 L freshwater left (??).

Day 3: Allegedly the day of “good corals”. We’ve been begging for the site Staghorn Point after every dive and it was promised for today in the afternoon. We got new towels today (both “clean” ones for the shower and ones for after the dives).

Dive 1: Delsan Wreck
Max depth 121ft, 60 mins, min water temp 83F.
Allegedly a group yesterday saw a whale shark here so we went whale shark hunting. Of course that meant we saw zero whale sharks. This was basically a bounce dive where we hit the bottom of the “crack” and then spent most of the dive at the top of the plateau. Saw some beautiful and large schools of jacks.

Dive 2: Delsan Wreck
Max depth 83ft, 63 mins, min water temp 84F.
We started all the way at the point, before it transitioned to Triggerfish City, due to the current. We didn’t see anything interesting until the second half of the dive, where there were a couple fully-grown barracudas. In addition, there were some nice patches of fingering porites and acroporas right before, at, and after the DW mooring line. Unfortunately it was not 100% coverage and still had a bunch of dead spots, most likely from bleaching.

Dive 3: Triggerfish City
Max depth 69ft, 67 mins, min water temp 84F.
BF got bit by a titan triggerfish on the leg while ascending to the safety stop. Luckily he was wearing a wetsuit so it didn’t hurt or leave a mark (and the wetsuit was unharmed too). At the end we saw very beautiful patches of isopora which was nice.

Apparently the vis was too bad for Staghorn Point because of the changing tides. We were just so disappointed because the staff reassured us several times that we would go… It would’ve been less heartbreaking if they didn’t confirm it.

Dive 4: Delsan Wreck
Max depth 67ft, 64 mins, min water temp 84F.
Instead of taking the dinghy, we did a giant stride off the back of the Narayana. We saw nothing until halfway through the dive when we had to turn because of the current. Unfortunately, the turning point that Job picked was right in front of the largest patch of healthy corals we’ve seen in all of Tubbataha, so we didn’t get to look at it at all.

Now down to 3,000 L of freshwater.

Day 4: We moved moorings around 4:30/5:00. Started the day with Staghorn Point so all was forgiven (:

Dive 1: Staghorn Point
Max depth 116ft, 64 mins, min water temp 83F.
Most consistent coral coverage in Tubbataha by far! While the species diversity is lower than other dive sites, the size and condition of coral colonies over several hundred meters is unmatched by any other site. Also the coral is deeper on average, making it easier to dive (3-10m instead of only 3m).

We moved to the north tip of the south atoll during the SI.

Dive 2: Black Rock
Max depth 111ft, 63 mins, min water temp 83F.
Edu said he saw a school of hammerheads at this site before which got everyone excited, but the most interesting sea life was only a school of bumbhead parrotfish (20? individuals) at the end of the dive. The mid to end corals of the dive were nice with mixed species; isopora, acropora, soft corals (growing over rubble).

We moved to the south tip of the north atoll during the SI.

Dive 3: Amos Rock
Max depth 82ft, 63 mins, min water temp 83F.
Nothing special.

We moved to the ranger station during the SI.

Dive 4: Ranger Station
Max depth 67ft, 54 mins, min water temp 83F.
Saw a pygmy seahorse!

After the dives were done for the day, we went to the ranger station to pay the park fees and so that we could buy tshirts. We saw 10+ turtles hanging out in the shallow sandbar around the station.

Ended the day with 1,800 L freshwater. During dinner we moved to the Wall Street mooring line for the night. Edu gave everyone a shot of rum for free (BF & I don’t drink on/around dive days).

Day 5: We moved to Jessie Beazley around 3:00.

Dive 1: Jessie Beazley
Max depth 125ft, 62 mins, min water temp 83F.
Better fishlife and both hard and soft coral than all of the rest of Tubbataha (except for Staghorn Point & Bird Islet).

Dive 2: Jessie Beazley
Max depth 92ft, 66 mins, min water temp 83F.
Absolutely tragic because we saw nothing and the other group saw two whale sharks.

After the dives we immediately started heading back to port and arrived around 21:00 to spend the night in the port. After dinner there was a half-hearted attempt to do karaoke but most people had gone to bed.

The next morning we ate breakfast (around 7:00) and left the boat around 9:30/10:00. Everyone was dropped off at their next destination.

Final thoughts: Tubbataha was not as exciting as we expected (coral-wise). In fact, it was extremely disappointing as it is treated as a last hold-out of good coral coverage in PH. We still rated Apo Reef (South Corner) higher. For big animals, we learned that it’s rather hit-or-miss unless you are in plankton season (~April). It would’ve been fine not seeing any big animals if not for the other group seeing whale sharks on the last dive of the whole LOB. Salt in the wound.
 
The boat looks like a Thai fishing boat.

I really doubt anyone would import Thai timber to Philippines to build a boat.
Luck plays a big part to see pelagic in Tubattaha because the Reefs in huge.
Fresh water!!!! Some divers can be really wasteful!! A very common sight after every dive on a multi-dive day boat.
 
Great contribution to the forum.

I'm really interested in Tubataha, I have 2 weeks penciled in next year for Ph, was planning to spend half of that in Tubbataha. It seems to me, given the high prices of many liveaboards (~3k USD for 5 days of diving), It's hard to justify.
 
The boat looks like a Thai fishing boat.
Yes, we thought so, too!
Edit: BF said the staff said the boat was imported from Thailand.

Luck plays a big part to see pelagic in Tubattaha because the Reefs in huge.
Yes, the guides said it was very unlikely outside of plankton season. Just very unfortunate that the other group saw whale sharks on the last dive of the whole LOB… oh well.

Fresh water!!!! Some divers can be really wasteful!! A very common sight after every dive on a multi-dive day boat.
I was very shocked at how fast the water was being used up. 50% after the first day…
 
It seems to me, given the high prices of many liveaboards (~3k USD for 5 days of diving), It's hard to justify.
Yes, it was quite expensive. The Narayana was one of the only “budget” options and ran around €2,000 per person.

Honestly if you cannot make it for plankton season, I would skip. The chance of seeing pelagics otherwise is too low for that amount of money. I believe that the “good” month (April) is sold out for next year already (or so the guides said).

If your goal is coral, then it’s definitely a skip for that amount of money.

We found that Apo Reef was a better deal (price, animals, corals). However, the Apo Reef LOBs usually run only ~3 days (or at least ours & the others I researched did).
 
Do you have any photos of the cabins and the boat?
 
Thanks for the thorough no-holds barred trip report! I think that (plus others on here) has confirmed my (somewhat deflated) decision to skip Tubbataha and by extension most of PH. It sounds like one's money is better spent elsewhere...
 
I think that (plus others on here) has confirmed my (somewhat deflated) decision to skip Tubbataha and by extension most of PH

Why on earth would you write off an entire country based on one lackluster report of a budget liveaboard to one area?
 

Back
Top Bottom