Mass Coral Reef Die-Off

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

merxlin

ScubaBoard Sponsor
ScubaBoard Sponsor
Messages
6,182
Reaction score
774
Location
So. Cal.
# of dives
500 - 999
Massive Indonesia Coral Die-off

We can pretend that things are not changing out there because of what it is called and your political position on Global warming, but the evidence is starting to pile up that something bad is happening to our ecosystem.

Mass Die-off at Coral Reef Triggered by 93-Degree Ocean

By OurAmazingPlanet Staff posted: 17 August 2010 12:40 pm ET

One of the most destructive and swift coral bleaching events ever recorded is underway in the waters off Indonesia, where water temperatures have climbed into the low 90s, according to data released by a conservation group this week.

The Wildlife Conservation Society (WCS) says a dramatic rise in sea temperature, potentially linked to global warming, is responsible for the devastation.

In May, the WCS sent marine biologists to investigate coral bleaching reported in Aceh — a province of Indonesia — located on the northern tip of the island of Sumatra. The initial survey carried out by the team revealed that more than 60 percent of corals in the area were bleached.

Subsequent monitoring of the Indonesian corals completed in early August revealed one of the most rapid and severe coral mortality events ever recorded. The scientists found that 80 percent of some species have died since the initial assessment, and more colonies are expected to die within the next few months.

"This is a tragedy not only for some of the world’s most biodiverse coral reefs, but also for people in the region, many of whom are extremely impoverished and depend on these reefs for their food and livelihoods," said WCS Marine Program Director Caleb McClennen. Coral reefs provide haven for fish and other creatures, and larger fish tend to congregate around reefs because they are good places to feed.

Bleaching — a whitening of corals that occurs when symbiotic algae living within coral tissues are expelled — is an indication of stress caused by environmental triggers such as fluctuations in ocean temperature. Depending on many factors, bleached coral may recover over time or die.

The event is the result of a rise in sea surface temperatures in the Andaman Sea — an area that includes the coasts of Myanmar, Thailand, the Andaman and Nicobar Islands and northwestern Indonesia. According to the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration's Coral Hotspots website, temperatures in the region peaked in late May at more than 93 degrees Fahrenheit (34 degrees Celsius). That's 7.2 degrees Fahrenheit (4 degrees Celsius) higher than long-term averages for the area.

"It's a disappointing development particularly in light of the fact that these same corals proved resilient to other disruptions to this ecosystem, including the Indian Ocean Tsunami of 2004," said WCS Indonesia Marine Program Director Stuart Campbell.

Surveys conducted in the wake of the 2004 tsunami revealed that the many reefs of Aceh were largely unaffected by this massive disturbance. Indeed, reefs severely damaged by poor land use and destructive fishing prior to the tsunami had recovered dramatically in the intervening years due to improved management. Government and community-managed areas in the region have been remarkably successful at maintaining fish biomass despite ongoing access to the reefs. But the bleaching and mortality in 2010 have rapidly reversed this recovery and will have a profound effect on reef fisheries.

Of particular concern is the scale of the warmer ocean waters, which the NOAA website indicates has affected the entire Andaman Sea and beyond. Similar mass bleaching events in 2010 have now been recorded in Sri Lanka, Thailand, Malaysia and many parts of Indonesia.

"If a similar degree of mortality is apparent at other sites in the Andaman Sea this will be the worst bleaching event ever recorded in the region," said Andrew Baird of James Cook University in Australia. "The destruction of these upstream reefs means recovery is likely to take much longer than before."

Efforts to bring back the reefs will have to be both local and global in scale, McClennen said.

"Immediate and intensive management will be required to try and help these reefs, their fisheries and the entire ecosystem recover and adapt," he said. "However, coral reefs cannot be protected from the warming ocean temperatures brought on by a changing climate by local actions alone. This is another unfortunate reminder that international efforts to curb the causes and effects of climate change must be made if these sensitive ecosystems and the vulnerable human communities around the world that depend on them are to adapt and endure."
 
I can't tell by the article. Is the coral bleached or dead? The mass bleaching event in the Maldives in 2006? has just about been completely recovered from. I'm not saying that we aren't destroying our climate, I'm just sayin'....
 
Get certified now folks, because the reefs aren't going to be here in 20 years.

Don't believe me? Go dive in Cozumel and Curacao (for example), then go dive the Florida Keys or the Bahamas.

Its like "Before" and "After".
 
Get certified now folks, because the reefs aren't going to be here in 20 years.

Don't believe me? Go dive in Cozumel and Curacao (for example), then go dive the Florida Keys or the Bahamas.

Its like "Before" and "After".

I disagree with your perception that the Bahamas and Florida Keys reefs are "not going to be here is 20 years". I started diving in Florida 10 years ago, when the reefs were at their worst. The change for the better in the quality and health of the reefs in that 10 years is astounding. I dive mainly in the Tortugas, where there is far less human impact than, say, Molasses or Sand Key, but studies are showing that I am right, the reef system in the Keys is improving (or has improved significantly, depending on location) once we became aware of a few different items, such as: It takes an ecosystem to make a reef. You can't have healthy reefs without fish. The Tortugas 2000 effort closed fishing in about half the coral reef in Tortugas, and we have consistently bigger and more numbers of fish than the rest of the keys, or the rest of the Tortugas. Dumping raw sewage on the reef tends to kill it. I know that the effort to bring the entire keys online with sewage treatment is kind of falling a bit short, but any is better than none. The nutrients from Sugar Cane production are fatal to the reef. Returning the everglades to a more natural state is making a difference.

Comparing Cozumel with the Bahamas is a bit like comparing NYC with San Francisco. Cozumel is washed with deep ocean currents as a part of the Yucatan current. Parts of the Bahamas are washed that way, too, and the diving is (IMHO) much better than Cozumel. Diving San Salvador or the Santaraan channel just isn't anything like Freeport or Nassau. It's just easier to dive Cozumel than it is to get to Cay Sal bank.

There are lots of dead reef in the world, the GBR comes to mind as a constant disappointment for me, but to say the world's reefs will be dead in 20 years is a bit of a stretch.
 
I can't tell by the article. Is the coral bleached or dead? The mass bleaching event in the Maldives in 2006? has just about been completely recovered from. I'm not saying that we aren't destroying our climate, I'm just sayin'....

From the article:

Bleaching — a whitening of corals that occurs when symbiotic algae living within coral tissues are expelled — is an indication of stress caused by environmental triggers such as fluctuations in ocean temperature. Depending on many factors, bleached coral may recover over time or die.

So the answer is yes, the coral may come back. But a 7 degree swing in tropical water is HUGE.
 
It's not just the amount of affected coral that is worrying scientists in Indonesia (and other locations) but also the rapid rate of decline - speeds not yet seen.
"The scientists found that 80 percent of some species have died since the initial assessment.." That initial assessment was in MAY!

Yes we have reasons to worry and be angry.
 
https://www.shearwater.com/products/swift/

Back
Top Bottom