I read some general info on Dive with Martin on the other threads; a couple questions:
1. Anything bad to say about his operation? (you can PM if you don't want to post)
i have seen nothing but favorable recs thus far
You need to decide what you are looking for in a dive shop first. DWM is a good safe operation for those looking for a very affordable and no frills operation. They have several boats, and get you to the sites quickly. There really aren't any "bad" shops on the island, just different types of operations.
2. How's the equipment?
Rental equipment in general is never going to be top of the line equipment. DWM does not charge for rental equipment, that should be some sort of indication for you. The only memorable complaints I can recall about DWM is regarding the rental equipment, but it's free with your package. You might consider renting equipment at your local dive shop or purchasing your own before you go.
3. My wife and I are intermediate divers- is DWM appropriate for us?
Of course they are. They accommodate all levels.
4. should we pre-book? (what about weather considerations)
Absolutely make reservations, if they even still have space. We are getting into high season and the better shops are booking up, that includes DWM. I would not wait until you get to the island, especially in November or you may find yourself diving with one of the large boat, high volume operations where you are just a number. As far as weather goes, who knows what the weather will be like. If it is too bad the harbor master will close the port. As far as specific weather policies, you will need to check with DWM.
5. where is the surface interval
Depends on where you dive. DWM sometimes stops at a beach and often they spend SI's on the boat.
6. Should we do our first night dive? (i know the answer to this one
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c5189/c51896754cb68cae40a1e4aa6cce06ce95147f43" alt="Winking ;) ;)"
)
Yes, you shoud definitely do a night dive in Cozumel. It will be a wonderful experience!
Most importantly...HAVE FUN!
thanks
12 days until coz!