Komodo LOB - how many dives have crazy currents?

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

BarnBrat

Registered
Messages
32
Reaction score
16
Location
Charlotte, NC
# of dives
100 - 199
I am an experienced diver - around 500 dives, 2 LOB trips to Raja Ampat and 10+ trips to Cozumel and many others all over the Carribean. I don’t mind flying go with the flow drift dives, or hooking in current to watch the show, but I’m not keen on diving unpredictable currents, especially in deep water.

I know some sites are notorious for bad currents, my question is on your average 10-12 night LOB approx many dive sites are known for really wild currents? We would time or trip to go near half moon but obviously that’s no guarantee and I know some sites will have wild current at any time. Thanks in advance!
 
I'm not an experienced diver and recently was in Komodo. I found it pretty manageable. The deepest dive we had was 26 m. The drift dives were not deep at all. It depends on the operation - some like it more sportive than others. There was only one dive which I would call "really wild" (Siaba Kecil) and the up/downwellings added to the fun. We did that twice (in opposite directions) and one time it was distinctly wilder. It all depends on the tide.

When it comes to predictability I found Alor much worse. Suddenly someone switched on the current at 30 m. Ooops. :oops:

If you've been to central Raja Ampat, you should be fine.
 
The most tricky one is the "Shotgun".
You can't make blanket statements like that in Komodo, as it all depends on the tide. We dove The Cauldron/Shotgun and it was pretty mild. One of the best dives though, with schooling jacks, schooling barracudas, sharks, two passing manta (or a manta and a mobula) a beautiful coral garden and tons of other fish. I completely underestimated this dive, since everybody always focuses on the thrilling "Shotgun" part.
 
You can't make blanket statements like that in Komodo, as it all depends on the tide. We dove The Cauldron/Shotgun and it was pretty mild. One of the best dives though, with schooling jacks, schooling barracudas, sharks, two passing manta (or a manta and a mobula) a beautiful coral garden and tons of other fish. I completely underestimated this dive, since everybody always focuses on the thrilling "Shotgun" part.
LOL.
Are you aware the title of this thread is about "crazy current"?
The thought of using reef hook on Shotgun must be a nightmare to you.
 
You can't make blanket statements like that in Komodo, as it all depends on the tide. We dove The Cauldron/Shotgun and it was pretty mild. One of the best dives though, with schooling jacks, schooling barracudas, sharks, two passing manta (or a manta and a mobula) a beautiful coral garden and tons of other fish. I completely underestimated this dive, since everybody always focuses on the thrilling "Shotgun" part.
@Plutonist has very good point! You can check Komodo tide chart here:


During rising or falling tide, the current can be sporty right at the entrance of the channel, but they are shallow and moving horizontally. You can just drift through the channel, kind of fun. You can see how diving in Shotgun is like in 20:27-24:23 time period of my trip video, below:



I haven’t experienced any down current in Komodo though in 7 Komodo dive trips from 2008 to 2024.
 
Good dive operators would check the tide chart and the current condition before taking you diving on the site.

If you go around August with calm sea in south Komodo, Manta Alley is an awesome place to dive.

 
I know some sites are notorious for bad currents, my question is on your average 10-12 night LOB approx many dive sites are known for really wild currents?
Firstly and after 5 times diving Komodo, my answer would be "it depends on the tide". A good operator will estimate the conditions and decide/inform how it should it should be dived.
For instance I have dived Crystal rock with lateral up and down currents especially near to the pinnacle tops where I almost lost my ear, I also dived the same spot at slack tide on full moon with absolutely zilch current (and for the record it was one of the best dives I had in Komodo, a foursome of manta rays chasing each other in cristal clear waters surrounded with schools of fish).

Secondly, currents even though strong or fast might not be that bad or crazy because they're horizontal and very predictable.
Typical is Shotgun where it can run fast while it's very easy to manage, also quite shallow, even divers with as few as 10-20 dives may enjoy the ride (anyway that's what the newbies on the small liveaboard I was on told me, not from my own opinion).

In my experience, I completely agree with post #2 the most difficult dive I had due to wild currents was on Siaba Kecil , because it was deeper, running fast sometimes straight, sometimes side ways (couldn't be down since we hit the bottom in the 30+ meters.
I woud state that sometimes Castle rock can be exhausting because you have to fight and hide against the current (a bit like Yellow corner in Alor).
North west of Komodo ( pulau Banta area) is also known for fierce currents, but like Plutonist and Dan said it will depend on the tide charts, I dived "High Voltage" with zero current as well, my guide told me it was the first time for him his divers could be able to venture out and have a "panorama" view of the walls.
Of course you don't want to go on the sides or the other side of Batu Bolong when the current is running and you really feel its power, but when you're staying on the protected side, it's an OW level dive. On a good day at the appropriate time, you can swim around with no current as well.

Anyway as a generic (hence approximate) answer to your question, I would say, expect 6-7 out of 10 dives with some current including 1 out of 10 wild currents (or 1 out of 20 depends on what you call crazy).

You can check Komodo tide chart here:
A single tide chart is not appropriate at the same time for all Komodo spots because it's a maze of islands and channels. the conditions would be completely different at the same time on a northern site and another central site. Plus some spots are recommended at raising tide while others might be more diveable at falling tide, etc.
Also since you're not diving every 6 hours at slack, a tide chart is not operational unless you are planning for a specific spot and you have no constraint with schedule.

One of the Komodo cruise directors pretended in the 2000s he had a logbook where he wrote a description of the currents on each spot for each period of the tide, hence the conditions to be dived and/or avoided as well as the average time difference between the official tide chart and the actual tide situation on the spot. Highly sought after or an urban diving legend?
 
siaba kecil and shotgun depending on the conditions (tide/moon phase). operator will generally make a decision based on checking the current right before the dive and the experience level of the group. both have relatively nearby sites to detour to that are easier.
 

Back
Top Bottom