Ireland's public safety dive team in hot water...

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

BladesRobinson

ScubaBoard Supporter
ScubaBoard Supporter
Scuba Instructor
Messages
643
Reaction score
48
Location
FLORIDA / LAT 27°39.133' / LON 080°22.261' / ICW M
I always find it interesting that despite locations, many teams have a lot in common. How many on this forum have complained about poor equipment, lack of manpower, poor management, leaking dry suits, etc. You are NOT alone and even our brothers overseas have similar problems, as evidenced below...


In depths of despair
Sunday, January 28, 2007
By Stephen Gordon


Northern Ireland has been without its own police diving team for a year, Sunday Life today reveals.

The PSNI's crack Underwater Search Unit - acclaimed for its brave work in often treacherous conditions - has been out of action since January 2006 when it was rocked by disciplinary moves against three of its six divers.

The trio were suspended and two more dedicated volunteers, both constables, withdrew their services as differences between divers and management came to a head.

Supporters of the suspended divers claim they are being "scapegoated" for failings in PSNI management.

A disciplinary case has still to be concluded and the PSNI's sole remaining diver cannot dive alone for health and safety reasons.

It has left the PSNI without the services of the unit, which is known for:

  • Recovering bodies from unpredictable seas, notably finding the remains of three generations of the Green family after their Kilkeel trawler the Tullaghmurry Lass sank in 2002.
  • Diving into stinking septic tanks to recover weapons or proceeds of crime.
  • Risking life and limb in pitch black canals and rivers, sometimes to recover bodies trapped under debris or in vehicles.
  • Vital security searches to protect VIP visitors.
Now Chief Constable Sir Hugh Orde is considering scrapping the USU and paying private contractors for the service. But police divers have written to Sir Hugh and to Policing Board chairman Sir Desmond Rea calling for the USU to be saved and warning against using civilians for police diving work.

Sources close to the unit have revealed the background to the unit being out of action.

The USU, which was founded in 1981 and is based at Lisnasharragh in east Belfast, once boasted 12 divers.

But by November 2004, partly due to Patten redundancies, its numbers had fallen to just six divers plus a sergeant who headed the team.

For safety reasons a minimum five divers are required for each operation and sources say the remaining divers were put under enormous pressure, carrying out more than 150 operations in 2005.

All the divers are constables who perform regular police duties but are on constant 24-hour call as USU volunteers - for no extra money.

"They are not even provided with mobile phones," said one source, who knows all the officers.

"The strain they were under was incredible. Family lives revolved around the USU. Birthdays, anniversaries, family trips, social occasions were regularly ruined as the men were called away to do dirty and dangerous work for no extra reward.

"The pressure was really telling on the families and the divers. What they had to put up with was unbelievable.

New diving suits were ordered which didn't fit, their cold weather gear leaked. They had suits inherited from former divers.

"Morale was low. The only thing that kept them going was the camaraderie within the unit and the satisfaction they got from doing a good job.

"They were especially proud of the Tullaghmurry Lass operation. They built up good relations with the Green family and were honoured to be asked to carry the coffins at the funeral."

In January 2005 Sir Hugh Orde hosted a special ceremony, attended by members of the Green family, at which the divers were presented with certificates for their work in that painstaking operation.

Twelve months later, the sinking of another fishing boat, The Greenhill off Ardglass with the loss of two men, sparked a crisis.

Sources close to the USU claim divers had warned police chiefs the unit was under-manned and poorly equipped.

Three divers were set to fly out in the early hours of January 20, 2006 for a well deserved foreign holiday, a break from the stress.

It is understood one had earlier ignored advice from a PSNI occupational health officer to take time off sick because of his devotion to the USU.

But on the evening of January 19, two were contacted to report for duty in the Greenhill search the following morning. A third only received a text which he didn't pick up until just hours before flying out on January 20.

The men refused the call to work, saying they were sick.

Supporters claim the men's annual leave had been booked well in advance and the PSNI should have called on divers from another UK force under the 'mutual assistance' programme.

Said one source: "Two of the three men were injured anyway and would have been unfit to dive in the Greenhill operation. The third would not have been able to dive without them, for safety reasons."

But the three cops were suspended from the USU, although not their regular duties, for failing to obey the order to turn up for duty.

A PSNI disciplinary panel - headed by ACC Alastair Finlay - heard evidence in the case for two days in November. It was adjourned and is expected to re-open shortly.

One source close to the divers said: "It is not the divers' fault. I believe they are being scapegoated for management failings.

"Senior officers had been warned the unit was under-resourced and the men were under great stress.

"These men have shown incredible dedication and loyalty to the USU.

"The investigation against them should never have gone so far.

"Now, Sir Hugh Orde is proposing to scrap the USU. But the divers are proud of the USU and want it up and running again after this disciplinary matter is finally resolved.

"They want assurances about manning levels, equipment, call-out status and other issues.

"But they believe binning the USU and getting civilians divers to their work would be a disaster."
 
Boy that sounds real familiar. In September, I will be with my unit for 10 years. I remember diving the best equipment I could afford, working for a Lieutenant who had zero diving experience and a Sergeant who lived his life in a bottle.:shakehead 3 team members were the norm for any call out and our vehicle usually broke down en route to the call. Our agency did contract with a private firm for a few dives, but quickly learned from that mistake.

10 years later we are properly equipped and trained. Our SOPs are in line with what agencies across the country are doing and moral is at a all time high. I attribute this to our current Lieutenant being a diver who has been with the team for 18+ years and a Sheriff who sees the importance of having properly equipped, and well trained staff to accomplish the given task.

Part of what helped us was we invited our Command Staff to training days and had them respond to some of our calls. This opened their eyes to what it is we do, and how important it is to have the proper equipment and training. I found out, after becoming an assistant team leader, if you mention liability to the bean counters, they will find the funds. Case in point; we needed to replace and O2/Trauma kit, as ours was becoming unserviceable. A 15 min. conversation with our "industrial hygenist" (AKA: slip, trip and fall guys as we refer to him as:wink: )resulted in a brand new kit being delivered within a week.

Education is the key. Even educating those who are above you is important. Now you won't get everything on a wish list, but pick and choose you battles wisely. Usually a well written proposal with justification for the items and showing the liability for not providing will get you futher.

While our team is nowhere near perfect, we are continually striving to become an ideal team. Public Safety Diving is evolving and agencies need to take notice and work with their teams to keep up. I hope our brothers and sisters across the pond can work their difficulties out. Hopefully their agency doesn't have to discover the pitfalls of contracting with commercial divers the way our agency did.
 
Divers exonerated... but underwater team still sunk!
[Published: Sunday 4, March 2007 - 11:05]

By Stephen Breen


Controversial disciplinary charges against three PSNI divers - which led to Northern Ireland being without its own police dive team for 14 months - have been dismissed by a tribunal.

Three members of the crack Underwater Search Unit - who were accused of failing to obey an order - were exonerated last week by a PSNI internal disciplinary panel.

Supporters of the three men had claimed they'd been "scapegoated" for failings in PSNI management.

A source close to the cleared divers told Sunday Life: "This case should never have been brought. These men have shown incredible devotion to duty with the USU.

"The men and their families are very relieved it is all over. It has dragged on for 14 months and has really has taken its toll.

"They've known all along that they did nothing wrong, but in the end, although cleared, they have received no apology or anything like it."

A panel of senior police officers ruled last week that the PSNI's Professional Standards Department had failed to prove the case against the men.

Sunday Life revealed in January this year how the disciplinary action had rocked the PSNI dive team, which has been acclaimed for its brave work in often treacherous conditions.

The PSNI had only six dedicated volunteer divers in its part-time USU.

In January 2006 three were suspended from diving duties, although not from their regular police duties.

Two more volunteers, both constables, withdrew their services as differences between divers and management came to a head.

That has left the PSNI without a dive team for 14 months and the service has had to bring in divers from other forces.

The background to the case is that the USU, which once boasted 12 volunteers, was down to six divers, plus a sergeant leader, by November 2004 - partly due to Patten-style redundancies.

For safety reasons at least five divers are required for each operation, and sources say the remaining volunteers were put under enormous pressure, carrying out more than 150 operations in 2005.

All the part-time divers are on constant 24-hour call as USU volunteers.

"The strain they were under was incredible. Family lives revolved around the USU. Family and social events were regularly ruined as the men were called away to do dirty and dangerous work for no extra reward."

Sources close to the USU claim divers had warned police chiefs the unit was under-manned and poorly equipped.

Three divers were set to fly out early on January 20, 2006 for a well deserved foreign holiday, a break from the stress. But on the night of January 19, two were contacted to report for duty in the Greenhill fishing boat search the following morning. A third only received a text that he didn't pick up until just hours before flying out on January 20. The men refused the calls to dive, saying they were sick.

A source said: "It is understood one had earlier ignored advice from a PSNI occupational health officer to take time off sick because of his devotion to the USU. Another had an injury."

Supporters claim the men's annual leave had been booked well in advance and the PSNI should have called on divers from another UK force under the 'mutual assistance' programme.

Said one source: "Two of the three men were injured anyway and would have been unfit to dive.

"The third would not have been able to dive without them for safety reasons."

On Tuesday last week the case against the men failed after the disciplinary panel heard medical evidence.
 

Back
Top Bottom