How to have a great dive

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

TSandM

Missed and loved by many.
Rest in Peace
ScubaBoard Supporter
Messages
36,349
Reaction score
13,706
Location
Woodinville, WA
Yesterday, I saw the old year out on a boat with seven other divers. It was a stunning day in Puget Sound, although very cold, with air temperatures in the high 20s and water temperatures in the high 40's. We did two different sites and we had a ball. Now, admittedly, everyone on the boat was VERY experienced -- I think the most novice has several hundred dives -- and had a lot of advanced training. But last night, I got to thinking about what it was that that experience and training gave us that allowed us to have a great, relaxed, stress-free and safe diving experience. Some of it, in the details, is specific to the system of diving I use, but a lot of it is simply basic principles that will help ANYBODY have a great day of diving.

1. Know your equipment. It's important to know your stuff. You should be able to set it up and check it for proper function. It's important to know how to use it when it's working properly, and how to diagnose problems and cope with them. Dealing with a leaking wing or dry suit inflator should not be a big deal, and neither should coping with an out-of-Argon emergency :) It's important to know potential failure modes, like exhaust diaphragm problems (which require either trying to inhale through a reg when the gas is off, or breathing in the water, to detect). It helps to know enough to check zipties for mouthpiece security. We all knew not to breathe regs extensive in that very cold air (setup for freeflow). It's an important safety matter, to know where the dump valve/s is/are and how to reach and use them. (This is something I'm always amazed at, when people who own their own BCs have no idea where any way to dump air is, except the inflator hose!)

Standardization makes it very easy for us to do a visual check on one another, and makes it easy to know what needs to be done to sort out any problems, and also makes it easy for folks to trade off spare parts. But the bottom line is that we know our gear and our buddy's gear, and can troubleshoot it.

2. Dive Planning. This starts with asking the right questions. We knew ahead of time what the sites were, and to find out how deep they were if we weren't familiar with them. This made it easy to assess the gas supply needed for the dive, and select the correct tanks. (Selecting tanks isn't always an option, and neither is knowing the sites ahead of time, but in that case, you compare the site information to the tanks you're given, and figure out what the profile is that you want to do. This is "gas management", and basic dive education often doesn't include much information about it.) Experience with difficult dives had taught us all to start gathering data from the moment the boat anchored, to decide the strategy for the dive. (For example, on the second dive, there was quite a bit of current on the surface, which led us to agree on a direction to start the dive, so that we could be sure we wouldn't come up downcurrent from the boat and be unable to regain it.)

Being able to reorganize as things change really IS something that comes with experience. But at least taking the data available from the boat deck and incorporating it into your dive planning is something everybody can learn to do.

Another part of dive planning is agreeing on contingency procedures, like what to do about buddy separation. Again, one of the strengths of a standardized system is that we didn't have to discuss that kind of thing, because we all got taught and follow the same procedures. But if you DON'T have that kind of common background, it's really important to settle the "what ifs" before you're sitting in the water by yourself, wondering what you should do, or what your buddy is going to do.

3. Diving skills. Buoyancy control is key to keeping a buddy team together on descent and ascent. These are critical times, because they are when things are rapidly changing, and a buddy's assistance is most likely to be needed. At the beginning of the dive is when you find out things aren't working, whether that's a faulty inflator or stuffed-up ears. At the end of the dive is where any weighting issues or problems with buoyancy control will become problematic, and where everyone is lowest on gas. It's a good time to keep your assistance and your spare gas close at hand!

Everybody had great skills for positioning themselves precisely in three dimensions. Hovering quietly, without sculling or using their hands, and moving through the dive site without disturbing the structure or the visibility, not only made the dive more fun, but contributed to achieving another necessity of a good dive, which is communication. We were using focused, high-intensity dive lights for passive communication, which is nice when you are moving along a wall and more or less need to be in single file. Keeping your hands and your body quiet is key when using lights in this way. We've all learned the hard way that if hand signals are necessary, they should be made slowly, deliberately, and unambiguously, and a meaningful response should come from one's buddy, so everybody is sure that the message has been understood (and agreed with!)

4. Safety. Although a lot of the things I've already listed contribute to safety, there are some very specific things that are also important. Everybody on that boat has practiced emergency procedures, from doing air-sharing, controlled ascents, to shooting bags, doing oral inflation, disconnecting inflator hoses, and coping with freeflows. This really is one of the differences between basic training and more advanced (technical or cave) training. In basic training you are introduced to all these procedures, but the importance of regular practice may not be stressed. In technical or cave training, it's ALL about having the knowledge and the skills to keep yourself OUT of trouble, but also to GET out of trouble if you're in it. What this really meant to the folks on the boat was that we all trusted one another to be able to achieve a high degree of self-rescue, and also to be able to function as a strong and capable assistant, should a situation exceed someone's own resources.

5. Judgement. Again, some of this comes out of the experience we all had. But knowing when to call it a day (current too strong, surface conditions too rough, diver tired or cold or just not with it) is a big part of ensuring a safe and stress-free day of diving. Knowing when to adjust the dive plan, either on the boat or once in the water, to do something shorter or shallower or otherwise more conservative, keeps people out of trouble. And knowing when it's reasonable to stretch a little, can save a good dive -- IF you have the skills to cope with the conditions you encounter.

At any rate, I thought I'd write this up, because if somebody is reading it and thinks, "Wow, I don't think I know that, or could do that," it might be motivation to learn or practice. I can certainly say that having a boat full of divers with these capacities makes for a smooth, relaxed and thoroughly enjoyable day of diving, because that's what we had!
 
Great post TS&M, very insightful. But, being a very simple man, I am just happy to be able to get down to Largo or Islamorada and occasionally to Coz to just jump off a boat and do some reef, drift or wreck diving, usually with a DM, and using my own gear except tank and weights. It's easy for me and doesn't take a lot of forethought. I always use an AL80, so weighting for buoyancy is a simple matter of choosing one of two amounts of lead depending on whether I am diving a full suit of just a shorty or no neoprene at all. It gets a little complicated when I dive with a backplate and horecollar though since I wear a neoprene vest to eliminate chafing. But the weight needed is so close to diving with a shorty that this mental obstacle is easily overcome since a little more weight than needed is no problem. The only planning I have to do is to make sure that I am at the dock by 8am in most instances. Safety is an on-going theme in all my dives so nothing extraterrestial enters the equation in that respect. As far as whether or not to make the dive, I rely on the captain's judgement as to whether the dive goes or is cancelled since I have no problem diving in rough seas so long as the boat remains afloat. Buoyancy comes natural and has gotten better over the 200+ dives I've done in the last 4 years. So diving is easy for me in most respects since most of the outside interference associated with the sport is pretty much taken care of and I can just enjoy the dive from giant stride to struggling back on the boat without pulling something or falling on my a** on the slippery deck and making a fool of myself.
 
Well, Garrobo, it seems to me that you have done most of the things I outlined in the original post -- you're familiar with your equipment, you know your weighting, you know what your skills are compared with the conditions where the dives in question are to be held. You don't have a choice of tanks, so you decide your profile. You said "buoyancy comes natural and has gotten better", so that's the skills portion. In short, you're an experienced diver with a big database of dives to draw on, and most of the things I talked about have become routine to you.

I'm not sure they are for newer divers, and what my intent with the post was, was to try to distill some of the things that come with advanced training and experience, because just telling people, "That will come with experience," or, "You need more experience to do that," doesn't tell them anything about WHAT they are going to or should get from said experience.
 
Yesterday I rang in the new year guiding two great dives!

The temps were a bit warmer and the vis likely much better, but there was current.

My guests were 3 under 25 y/o brothers with no dives after last years holiday Caribbean certification and 3 under 30 y/o guys with one boat trip after their 3 years ago certifications. I was also shooting pics of the 3 brothers.

They had never used any of the dive equipment, but one had his own fins and mask. They had never been in a cavern and never been to a Lanai dive site, but the two best divers of the group (different brothers) made all of their 4 lifetime dives at Molokini with B&B. :thumb:

They listened to the briefings, paid attention to the crews instructions and followed direction underwater.

Out of 13 divers on the boat yesterday, only one had most of what TS&M describes above, and he was on his second Fosters when I climbed up the ladder after the second dive. :idk:

Having a boat full of divers with TS&M's listed capacities is not always necessary for a smooth, relaxed and thoroughly enjoyable day of diving, because that's what we didn't have! :D
 
I'm glad you had a great dive. I hope you didn't mean to imply that the things I listed that come with experience aren't useful, or that less experienced divers shouldn't try to acquire them?
 
Yesterday, I saw the old year out on a boat with seven other divers. It was a stunning day in Puget Sound, although very cold, with air temperatures in the high 20s and water temperatures in the high 40's. We did two different sites and we had a ball. Now, admittedly, everyone on the boat was VERY experienced -- I think the most novice has several hundred dives -- and had a lot of advanced training. But last night, I got to thinking about what it was that that experience and training gave us that allowed us to have a great, relaxed, stress-free and safe diving experience. Some of it, in the details, is specific to the system of diving I use, but a lot of it is simply basic principles that will help ANYBODY have a great day of diving.

1. Know your equipment. It's important to know your stuff. You should be able to set it up and check it for proper function. It's important to know how to use it when it's working properly, and how to diagnose problems and cope with them. Dealing with a leaking wing or dry suit inflator should not be a big deal, and neither should coping with an out-of-Argon emergency :) It's important to know potential failure modes, like exhaust diaphragm problems (which require either trying to inhale through a reg when the gas is off, or breathing in the water, to detect). It helps to know enough to check zipties for mouthpiece security. We all knew not to breathe regs extensive in that very cold air (setup for freeflow). It's an important safety matter, to know where the dump valve/s is/are and how to reach and use them. (This is something I'm always amazed at, when people who own their own BCs have no idea where any way to dump air is, except the inflator hose!)

Standardization makes it very easy for us to do a visual check on one another, and makes it easy to know what needs to be done to sort out any problems, and also makes it easy for folks to trade off spare parts. But the bottom line is that we know our gear and our buddy's gear, and can troubleshoot it.

2. Dive Planning. This starts with asking the right questions. We knew ahead of time what the sites were, and to find out how deep they were if we weren't familiar with them. This made it easy to assess the gas supply needed for the dive, and select the correct tanks. (Selecting tanks isn't always an option, and neither is knowing the sites ahead of time, but in that case, you compare the site information to the tanks you're given, and figure out what the profile is that you want to do. This is "gas management", and basic dive education often doesn't include much information about it.) Experience with difficult dives had taught us all to start gathering data from the moment the boat anchored, to decide the strategy for the dive. (For example, on the second dive, there was quite a bit of current on the surface, which led us to agree on a direction to start the dive, so that we could be sure we wouldn't come up downcurrent from the boat and be unable to regain it.)

Being able to reorganize as things change really IS something that comes with experience. But at least taking the data available from the boat deck and incorporating it into your dive planning is something everybody can learn to do.

Another part of dive planning is agreeing on contingency procedures, like what to do about buddy separation. Again, one of the strengths of a standardized system is that we didn't have to discuss that kind of thing, because we all got taught and follow the same procedures. But if you DON'T have that kind of common background, it's really important to settle the "what ifs" before you're sitting in the water by yourself, wondering what you should do, or what your buddy is going to do.

3. Diving skills. Buoyancy control is key to keeping a buddy team together on descent and ascent. These are critical times, because they are when things are rapidly changing, and a buddy's assistance is most likely to be needed. At the beginning of the dive is when you find out things aren't working, whether that's a faulty inflator or stuffed-up ears. At the end of the dive is where any weighting issues or problems with buoyancy control will become problematic, and where everyone is lowest on gas. It's a good time to keep your assistance and your spare gas close at hand!

Everybody had great skills for positioning themselves precisely in three dimensions. Hovering quietly, without sculling or using their hands, and moving through the dive site without disturbing the structure or the visibility, not only made the dive more fun, but contributed to achieving another necessity of a good dive, which is communication. We were using focused, high-intensity dive lights for passive communication, which is nice when you are moving along a wall and more or less need to be in single file. Keeping your hands and your body quiet is key when using lights in this way. We've all learned the hard way that if hand signals are necessary, they should be made slowly, deliberately, and unambiguously, and a meaningful response should come from one's buddy, so everybody is sure that the message has been understood (and agreed with!)

4. Safety. Although a lot of the things I've already listed contribute to safety, there are some very specific things that are also important. Everybody on that boat has practiced emergency procedures, from doing air-sharing, controlled ascents, to shooting bags, doing oral inflation, disconnecting inflator hoses, and coping with freeflows. This really is one of the differences between basic training and more advanced (technical or cave) training. In basic training you are introduced to all these procedures, but the importance of regular practice may not be stressed. In technical or cave training, it's ALL about having the knowledge and the skills to keep yourself OUT of trouble, but also to GET out of trouble if you're in it. What this really meant to the folks on the boat was that we all trusted one another to be able to achieve a high degree of self-rescue, and also to be able to function as a strong and capable assistant, should a situation exceed someone's own resources.

5. Judgement. Again, some of this comes out of the experience we all had. But knowing when to call it a day (current too strong, surface conditions too rough, diver tired or cold or just not with it) is a big part of ensuring a safe and stress-free day of diving. Knowing when to adjust the dive plan, either on the boat or once in the water, to do something shorter or shallower or otherwise more conservative, keeps people out of trouble. And knowing when it's reasonable to stretch a little, can save a good dive -- IF you have the skills to cope with the conditions you encounter.

At any rate, I thought I'd write this up, because if somebody is reading it and thinks, "Wow, I don't think I know that, or could do that," it might be motivation to learn or practice. I can certainly say that having a boat full of divers with these capacities makes for a smooth, relaxed and thoroughly enjoyable day of diving, because that's what we had!

Sounds freaking boring. Where are the moments of sheer terror that give spice to the typical recreational dive? :D:D:D
 
Sounds freaking boring. Where are the moments of sheer terror that give spice to the typical recreational dive?

Oh, we get those when the octopuses try to steal our regulators!
 
I'm glad you had a great dive. I hope you didn't mean to imply that the things I listed that come with experience aren't useful, or that less experienced divers shouldn't try to acquire them?

I am definitely implying that from a Basic Scuba Discussions forum perspective, a boat dive in Puget Sound when the air temps are in the high 20's and the water temps are in the high 40's is not really Basic Scuba.

If we just say that to be basic scuba at least 50% of the divers in the world would have tried it; what percentage of world wide divers have tried BP/W, dry suits, argon, all of the above and more on the same dive?

I am definitely saying that for the vast majority of basic divers on the planet and on this board, many of the things you have listed are not useful.

It really sounds like you are trying to sell something; how much money and time have you spent on dive training, equipment and travel in the last 5 years? Not to mention over 20,000 posts on SB? Does that kind of dive life really have much to do with Basic Scuba?

If we follow the forum format of ScubaBoard, isn't the discussion you are starting more appropriate in the Technical Diving forum? If a PADI Master Diver is the middle of the target range for the Advanced Scuba Discussions forum I still think this thread would be in the wrong forum.

Either the general section of the Technical Diving Specialties or your local Sub Forum; you do have a local sub forum, don't you?

I have a lot of basic scuba experience; some of those things you listed are not things basic scuba divers ever experience or need to experience so I question their usefulness. I do not think basic scuba divers should worry about acquiring some of those things.
 
Last edited:
Halemano: If you live around the Sound or where I live in Ohio I'd say that 20 degree air and 40's degree water IS pretty basic this time of year. Just like where I do my diving, 75 degree air and 75 degree water is the usual in January.
 
halemanō;5660329:
I am definitely implying that from a Basic Scuba Discussions forum perspective, a boat dive in Puget Sound when the air temps are in the high 20's and the water temps are in the high 40's is not really Basic Scuba.
But it is pretty basic around here ... dive boats go out in those conditions with all sorts of divers aboard, from the very experienced to those who just got certified.

I'd be willing to bet that's true pretty much anywhere in the world where people dive in cold water environments.

halemanō;5660329:
If we just say that to be basic scuba at least 50% of the divers in the world would have tried it; what percentage of world wide divers have tried BP/W, dry suits, argon, all of the above and more on the same dive?

I am definitely saying that for the vast majority of basic divers on the planet and on this board, many of the things you have listed are not useful.
... and many are. I'd say talking about those things and letting people decide as individuals whether or not they are useful is a good thing.

halemanō;5660329:
It really sounds like you are trying to sell something; how much money and time have you spent on dive training, equipment and travel in the last 5 years? Not to mention over 20,000 posts on SB? Does that kind of dive life really have much to do with Basic Scuba?
I don't understand what your objection is ... nor why you feel the need for the personal attack.

halemanō;5660329:
If we follow the forum format of ScubaBoard, isn't the discussion you are starting more appropriate in the Technical Diving forum?
Nothing in her post is exclusive to technical diving ... or even particularly applicable at the level she's presented it.

halemanō;5660329:
If a PADI Master Diver is the middle of the target range for the Advanced Scuba Discussions forum I still think this thread would be in the wrong forum.

Either the general section of the Technical Diving Specialties or your local Sub Forum; you do have a local sub forum, don't you?

I have a lot of basic scuba experience; some of those things you listed are not things basic scuba divers ever experience or need to experience so I question their usefulness. I do not think basic scuba divers should worry about acquiring some of those things.
You seem to be implying that unless someone dives as you do, they don't belong here.

I don't understand that logic ... and I certainly don't agree with it.

Different perspectives are what makes this forum valuable. Rather than attacking Lynne, why don't you try offering some of your own perspectives on how to have a great dive? That might actually add something useful to the conversation ...

... Bob (Grateful Diver)
 
https://www.shearwater.com/products/swift/

Back
Top Bottom