All I remember about the 1960's-era double-hose was that they flooded if you rolled upside down.
They made us use them for at least a couple sessions in my 1971 certification class, in case we ran across one as a rental (some were still around, I guess). Don't think I've ever seen one used in a contemporary recreational tank setup.
This is not exactly correct, not meaning to be dismissive.
First, plenty of people still use the double hose regulators, enough so that they have become a cottage industry. Not all twin hosers are born equal, the USD Aqua Masters and original Mistral and various Voit units are excellent for diving even today. The Aqua Masters can be adapted to support modern configurations. I dive a Hog rig, Oxy Mach V with a Phoenix Royal Aqua Master.
Second, it is not true exactly that they flood if you go upside down. Very early, back in the 50s, twin hose regulators had open mouthpieces, these could and would flood and required knowing how to roll to clear etc. By the late 50s and early 60s twin hose regulators were equipped with cage valves in the mouthpiece that virtually eliminated flooding and made purging very easy. You still need to know the "old" methods just in case but I cannot recall ever having to roll to clear or flooding with a Aqua Master in normal operation. It can happen if the cage valves are torn or missing. It really just is not a big deal. I am sure the usual suspects will show up to defend the twin hose.
Yes, an Aqua Master is very quiet, very smooth, no bubbles in your face or ears. The original Mistral single stage has a jet venturi that goes woosh, woosh when you inhale so it is not quiet like the Aqua Master. It is so easy to sneak up on fish who normally run from a single hose diverand the fish get the most surprised look when you do.
The modern and now discontinued Mistral while not totally unfortuante is not an equal to the old Aqua Masters. It is sort of a junkyard parts shelf Frakenstien monster put together by a company that has forgotten where they came from to begin with. Not a very good attempt. In fact, it was downright, uh, Frankenstienish and totally clunky compared to the real deal.
A friend drifts by at Silver Springs last weekend:
Me on the deck of the Mighty O at 140 feet:
Single hose, how do you guys live with those things?
N, double hose since 1966 with a little single hose interlude in there