-----
Bonaire vs. Curacao (one of the more discussed comparisons on Scuba Board; each is preferred by some. Both offer abundant shore diving ‘freedom’ and similar climate).
-----1.) Bonaire is smaller & less populous; said to have less to do topside (drive through Washington-Slagbaai Park, visit the Donkey Sanctuary, kite board, wind surf, eat out). Curacao’s capital
Willemstad dwarfs Bonaire’s,
Kralendijk.
-----2.) Bonaire’s diving is mainly west coast, and it’s small enough anywhere you stay nearby will suffice. Yes, transit from the hilly north to the flat south (& back) between resort and farthest shore dive sites can be a drive. Curacao is larger to the point where you stay will have a greater impact on your experience; the diving’s reputedly better out west, but the topside is more rustic. There’s more to do topside closer to Willemstad.
-----3.) Bonaire has mainly ‘ironshore’ – varies from fairly smooth gravel-like mass of oblong worn, dead coral ‘pellets’ to very rough, sometimes sharp, jagged rock – so entries & exits can be tough – don’t turn your ankle! Curacao has a lot of sandy beach. I’ve seen conflicting opinions on whether Curacao shore sites have longer swim-outs, but some said so (DiverSteve
Post #10).
-----4.) Bonaire has a west coast-hugging main road (most diving is along this coast); getting site-to-site is pretty fast, easy and straight-forward. Curacao’s road paralleling the most-dove coast is often well-inland; you take side-roads out to the dive sites, some of which can be harder to find. Catskill Diver noted some roads to sites aren’t marked as well (
Post #15), and Ronski101 (
Post #1, May 2016) noted, after 7 shore dives, roads wandered all over the place with no signs and no painted rocks to guide tourists like Bonaire.
-----5.) Western Curacao is bisected by a main road that splits mid-island, one branch running closer to the water till they reunite in Westput; from that branch most dive sites at ~ 5-15 minutes on a secondary road (based on
Post #4 by DiverSteve).
-----6.) Curacao’s much wider offering of sandy beaches offers easier entries/exits for divers, and recreation for non-diving beach lovers.
-----7.) Bonaire is smaller, but the population far less, so it’s got a simpler, easy-to-get-around ‘feel’ to it. You won’t see a pontoon bridge!
-----8.) Airfare to Curacao is often a bit cheaper; airfare’s ridiculous U.S.-to-Bonaire, though dividing total trip cost by total # of dives (padding your count with shore diving) can make either a good deal.
-----9.) Most Bonaire shore dive sites are ‘rustic’ – there are no onsite dive shops for tanks, concession stands, chairs & beach umbrellas, etc… A number of Curacao sites (not all) have such ‘amenities,’ sometimes with a ‘usage fee’ – and it’s often possible to rent tanks at the dive site. Bonaire dive packages usually entail a rental pick-up truck and unlimited 80-cf AL tanks (nitrox usually a free upgrade) for shore diving, so you load your tanks & gear into your truck, hit the road and dive where you will.
-----10.) Bonaire has a donkey sanctuary and Curacao has an ostrich farm. Curacao has offerings (e.g.: the Sea Aquarium) Bonaire can’t match.
-----11.) My subjective impression from reading trip reports has been driven divers tend to average higher dive counts on a Bonaire trip.
-----Despite all that, I like Bonaire’s simplicity, west coast-hugging road and fast site-to-site travel time, and don’t like usage fees. It’s a very personal decision. Our beach-loving 5-year old would have a very different opinion.
*Solo Diving: Browsing online content one might infer Curacao is somehow unfriendly to solo diving; as of 7-21-18, The Dive Bus’s
safety policy states “No solo diving, even if you’re certified as such” and Ocean Encounters’
Important Information page states “Solo Diving is not allowed under any circumstance.” A common response to such restrictive policies is rent tanks and go dive without announcing your intentions or doing it in front of them, but that could make some house reef diving difficult. Go West Diving’s FAQ re: Is solo diving allowed – “For both your own safety and our dive shop policies and security standards we do not allow and support solo diving. For single diver we offer daily 2-tank boat dives in the morning and 1-tank afternoon boat dives. Of course also guided shore dives can be arranged for you.”
That bites. The diving freedom of shore-diving destinations is very appealing to soloists. Do we keep sneaking around (or opting for Bonaire)? In the Jan. 2018 thread Curacao – A Unique Shore Diving Haven, Andreas (
Post #5) noted regarding their current solo diving policy they’d switched from a strict no solo-diving policy to crediting solo dive training certifications as long as the diver agreed to use appropriate equipment including redundant air supply (they had no dedicated solo diving equipment to rent). Noting their website later still indicated no solo diving, I e-mailed and per reply 8-3-18 from Floris with Go West Diving, they still had the same opinion Andreas gave earlier, didn’t nor intend to advertise with solo diving at the moment, accepted solo divers with all equipment needed in redundancy, and said I could rent tanks with them – that wouldn’t be a problem. He reiterated they don’t advertise with solo at the moment. If you intend to solo dive with Go West as your tank provider, I suggest contacting them in advance for current policy.