1. (Q) "We're debating Cozumeleno vs. Fiesta Americana. Any suggestions? My wife and I will both be doing our second dive after PADI Open Water Cert. We enjoy colorful coral and interesting sealife. We also like a nice beach to lay out on and snorkel off of."
(A) EC is far north, while FA is far south. About a $3 cab ride o/w to town from EC, about $6 o/w from FA.
FA is much closer to the commonly dived reefs, so near that most surface intervals will be back at the resort. Southern reefs are a long boat ride from EC, so surface intervals will be at one of the commercial beaches down that way
EC has the better beach & is right on it. FA 's is across the main road, mostly man-made & smallish.
EC has far better snorkeling.
BTW, I think EC's food is better.
2 (Q) "Is there a good resort to trust our children with while we dive?"
(A) EC is probably a bit more family oriented, but both are generally considered fully trustworthy in this regard.
3. (Q) "Is it worth staying a couple days in Playa Del Carmen to see the cenotes?"
(A) It is in my opinion. Very different than ocean diving. Also, PDC has a different feel than Coz & should be experienced.
4. (Q) "Is Isla de Mujeres worth seeing (during spring break)?"
(A) I would not take time away from Coz & PDC in order to see it.
Helpful?
DocVikingo