barracuda or needlefish attack on spearfisherman- o'ahu

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

ch0ppersrule

Contributor
Messages
1,587
Reaction score
1
Location
Colorado
# of dives
200 - 499
Barracuda suspected
in rare attack
on isle diver

By Mary Vorsino
mvorsino@starbulletin.com

Just before the attack, Tonga Loumoli remembers spotting several sharks -- seemingly sniffing his catches.

They left him alone, though.

Rather, it was another fish that landed Loumoli in the intensive-care unit at the Queen's Medical Center with a 6-inch-long gash to his abdomen and potentially irreparable damage to his liver.

In a highly unusual incident, a 4-foot-long fish that Loumoli is certain was a barracuda charged into the 19-year-old's stomach while he was night diving Thursday off Kahana Bay near Kaaawa. When the animal wriggled loose, it left behind a substantial wound and a tooth.

"It came full strength and hit him from the front, on the stomach," Loumoli's mother, Paea, said yesterday. "It ran straight into him."

Doctors say the Mililani resident is lucky to be alive. He is also quite fortunate to have been swimming with Braven Rivera, a quick-thinking buddy, who threw Loumoli into a small dinghy, dragged him nearly a mile to shore and flagged down an officer who called for help.

If it was indeed a barracuda that impaled Loumoli, the incident could be the first of its kind recorded in the islands, according to marine expert Craig Thomas.

The fish have been known -- though rarely -- to bite and leave serious wounds, but Thomas said he has never heard of a barracuda charging into a swimmer.

"Nothing's impossible," he said, "but I'd be very surprised."

He said it seems more likely that Loumoli was impaled by a needlefish.

But Loumoli, who has been night diving since his freshman year in high school, is adamant that he was attacked by a barracuda.

"I saw clearly -- it was a barracuda," agreed Rivera, the friend Loumoli was diving with Thursday night. "It was a big one."

A tooth the fish left behind could solve the mystery and should be examined, Thomas said.

The attack happened about 11:35 p.m. when Loumoli and Rivera, 44, were spearfishing in 6- to 8-foot waters about a mile offshore. The two frequent the spot and know it well.

According to his mother, Loumoli was wearing a headlight and a silver necklace. A barracuda would have likely been attracted to the necklace, Thomas said, while a light would have attracted a needlefish.

During the dive, Loumoli told his mother, the duo "met a lot of sharks, but they were never bothered by them." Then they saw what they believe was a barracuda.

It swam past Loumoli slowly before making a sharp right-angle turn and ramming into him. "It happened so quickly," said Paea Loumoli, who got a call just before midnight Thursday that her son was at Queen's and headed into surgery.

Loumoli, a student at Remington College in Honolulu, suffered serious liver damage, although doctors were still assessing its extent, according to his mother.

He is on a machine to help his breathing and so could not talk about the incident. He is able to respond with hand signs, though, and has written notes to his mother and sister about the attack.

One of the first things he scribbled down when he woke up yesterday was, "I'm going to quit diving."

Paea Loumoli said she has long been worried about her son's late-night hobby and has encouraged him to concentrate on his music instead. The teen is a member of a Tongan band, Naati Moonia.

"When he goes diving, I can't sleep," Paea Loumoli said during a break from watching over her son. "It's always worried me and scared me to death."

It is unclear when Loumoli will get out of the hospital, but doctors are hopeful he will be moved from the intensive care unit before the weekend is over.

Loumoli, his mother said, usually fishes for his church and family members. Thursday night, he was trying to stock up on fish for an upcoming visit from his grandparents.

And just that morning, he had celebrated his father's 50th birthday.

Loumoli now "has a scar to give his father," his mother said with a quiet laugh.
 
How bizzare. Makes me want to believe the 2 boys were screwing around and this was their cover story, but I don't know.

I can also see the confusion between the 2 fish would cause difficulty in identifying it.
 
I have seen several barracuda at E. Beach and 2 at Firehouse, but they never gave me a second glance. I have seen alot in cozumel and they too never bothered to get close. I have even done a back roll into a school of 8-10. They dive master said "Lady, barracuda under you" as I was starting the roll. As you know, once you start it is impossible not to keep going. Well, nothing happened. I don't know what you have to do to provoke them to attack, but I guess I have been lucky. Maybe it had something to do with them spearfishing??
 
ch0ppersrule:
I have seen several barracuda at E. Beach and 2 at Firehouse, but they never gave me a second glance. I have seen alot in cozumel and they too never bothered to get close. I have even done a back roll into a school of 8-10. They dive master said "Lady, barracuda under you" as I was starting the roll. As you know, once you start it is impossible not to keep going. Well, nothing happened. I don't know what you have to do to provoke them to attack, but I guess I have been lucky. Maybe it had something to do with them spearfishing??

If it was a barracuda then it had everything to do with spearfishing. I also swim around them a lot in Florida. All the "attacks" I've heard of involved spearfishing.
 
Qweevox:
If it was a barracuda then it had everything to do with spearfishing. I also swim around them a lot in Florida. All the "attacks" I've heard of involved spearfishing.

Spearfishing was probably a factor...so was shiney articles reflecting light on a night dive. Actually. most of the barracuda attacks that I'm familiar with have been unprovoked...also many of them have happened at night. Barracuda have two sets of teeth...one for cutting, the other for grabbing and clinging to the prey. It will be interesting to see what tooth identification reveals.

In February of 2003, I experienced an unprovoked barracuda attack that could have been fatal. It was also on a night dive. (Previously discussed on this board and documented with DAN) These fish strike with incredible speed (40mph) and a four foot 'cuda is pushing some mass at 40mph!

Here's wishing a speedy recovery to the young man. I would like to hear from him personally when he recovers....there are some of us around the world ('cuda attack survivors) who stay in touch and try to keep up with these things because we have a personal interest.

Regards,
 
Cudabait:
Actually. most of the barracuda attacks that I'm familiar with have been unprovoked...also many of them have happened at night.

how do you provoke a barracuda?


drag fishguts with you in the water and confuse it as to what's what?

dangle reflective objects and again confuse it as to your identity?

confuse it at night, with lights and pieces of equipment dangling and shining?


i don't think "unprovoked" is the right word... more like "confused"

and you are right... i don't know of ANY barracuda incident where the barracuda
was not confused about the nature of who it was bitting into

confuse the barracuda into thinking you are prey, on the other hand... and... ouch
 
Experienced finning along a giant barracuda. Well actually I was just minding my own business when he suddenly swam up beside me. He was almost within reach. Took me by surprise cuz I glanced in the direction he came from a couple of seconds before and it wasn't even there. Started backing away and he finally swam off.

Question is: If a barracuda does attack, what's the best course of action?
 
hchen:
Experienced finning along a giant barracuda. Well actually I was just minding my own business when he suddenly swam up beside me. He was almost within reach. Took me by surprise cuz I glanced in the direction he came from a couple of seconds before and it wasn't even there. Started backing away and he finally swam off.

Question is: If a barracuda does attack, what's the best course of action?


These suggestions are based only on experience:

Maintain air supply
Remain as calm as possible
Seek quickest assistance (buddy or other)
Immediate exit of water and control of bleeding
Seek immediate medical attention and contact DAN...they are the most likely to be able to direct you to the nearest/most capable services needed, particularly foreign.

Also keep in mind that infection is a major consideration, regardless of wound size. Antibiotics will be a MUST!

The probability is that one will not be able to anticipate an attack or see one coming. (I did not).

Regards,
 
And the unaddressed question:

I am unclear as to where they are getting needlefish from. I have never heard of a needlefish attack/impaling. Has such a thing ever been documented? Also, if they did pull a tooth out of him, I would think it would be quite difficult to mistake a cuda tooth with a needlefish tooth.
 
https://www.shearwater.com/products/swift/

Back
Top Bottom