A rant and a question about equipment reliability

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

Messages
4
Reaction score
0
Location
Tallahassee, FL
My buddy Charlie and I had met last weekend at the LDS before our dive. We got some fills and he was getting some repairs for some of his gear that didn‘t work, I‘m not sure what. We went out and had an absolutely great first dive, possibly my best dive ever. The hose for my second stage started leaking before the second dive. A new O ring solved that. When I backrolled into the water the clip for my fin strap fell off and sank. No spare for that, it killed the dive.

Now that I think about it, I’ve seen a mountain of these idiotic little failures. Straps, clips, buckles and O rings seem to be the big offenders but I’ve seen Charlie have a full blast free-flow failure on a dive a few years ago. He had a tank strap fail once, too. My other dive buddy James had his new computer fail on the first dive. He sat out a very expensive boat dive with a leaking SPG (no refunds for gear failure.) On the same trip, the strap for my mask came loose and my mask fell overboard. Fortunately someone grabbed it and someone else had a spare strap or I‘d have sat out, too. I’ve been on about 10 boat dives and two other times I’ve seen someone left aboard with a gear failure. Mark, another dive buddy, has problems of every sort, though he also dives a hodgepodge of used equipment. But another buddy, Chris, arrives with equipment worth three times as much as the car it arrived in, and he has some dumb failures too. Reliability doesn’t seem to be strongly price related.

I’ve been diving a few years but I’ve only owned my own equipment for about a year (and I also admit I really shopped “price” for my first set of gear.) In the last year my new SPG has been sent back for warrantee service. I’ve had to replace (supposedly new) tank O rings on my own tank and on other peoples tanks. The hose and then the hand piece of my BC inflator hose split and had to be replaced. The sewing that prevents the waist strap buckle from coming off came out, I had to re-do that. Other less important stitches have failed, too. The clip for my new snorkel broke the first day. My spear gun trigger fell apart. I’ve had a stuck purge button on my brand new octopus that scared the **** out of me. My depth gauge inexplicably turned itself around in the console and I broke it getting it out. My pony bottle leaks pressure and the fill adaptor has a small part that I must be very careful not to lose because it falls out every time I use it. I’m probably forgetting one or two other incidents as well.

I’m now carrying a ton of spare parts with me because some little do-dad goes bad all the time. Last weekend was the second time my spares kit saved a dive, and it would have been the third if I only had a spare fin strap buckle (for the freakin’ BRAND NEW fins I paid too much for.)

Scuba gear has far too many tiny showstoppers.

I dive with 4 guys regularly, all just recreational divers but all covering the full spectrum of gear pricing. None of us seem to have gear that‘s all that reliable. Getting 4 divers with 4 working sets of gear through a day of diving without a problem almost seems to be the exception. Arraigning dive trips, I can often count on one of them saying “No, I can’t go. My ____(insert the name of some piece of dive equipment)___ is busted.” I get totally nuts about it, they seem to just take it as part of the sport.

Rant over, but what’s the deal? Does this ever get better as you work out all the bugs? Or should I just enlarge my spares kit?
 
Do you and your buddies use your gear as a substitute for hammers when one isn't handy?! :chicken:

Your experiences are many times worse than what I've experienced in 500 dives.

The only failure that ever came close to stopping me from diving was the plastic clip that holds the strap onto the mask, and that I was able to fix with tiewraps while we were still on the approach for dropping on the wreck.
 
I think you're going to find that your experiences are the exception, not the rule. I can't remember the last time someone couldn't dive because of equipment failure - unless you count a frozen reg in the icy winter.

Forgotten gear - that's another story... ;)

Charlie99:
The only failure that ever came close to stopping me from diving was the plastic clip that holds the strap onto the mask, and that I was able to fix with tiewraps while we were still on the approach for dropping on the wreck.
OK, I will admit to a couple of times when duct tape or zip ties saved the day. :D
 
Charlie99:
Do you and your buddies use your gear as a substitute for hammers when one isn't handy?! :chicken:

Your experiences are many times worse than what I've experienced in 500 dives.

The only failure that ever came close to stopping me from diving was the plastic clip that holds the strap onto the mask, and that I was able to fix with tiewraps while we were still on the approach for dropping on the wreck.

I have to agree with Charlie, I haven't had nearly the problems with gear that you've had. I try to use the KISS ( Keep It Simple, Stupid)theory when buying and using gear. I use force fins that have the bungee straps, my 'puter is wrist mounted so I have a smaller, more streamlined console, and I bought a fishing tackle box and keep spare O-rings, mask straps, grease, and tools as a save-a-dive kit.
I've had little nuisance problems, but the last thing to make me miss a scheduled dive was forgetting my reg...Oops :errrr:
Does your buddy's name happen to be Murphy? J/K
Here's to better luck in the future,
Chris
 
Just like you I carry a full tool box of spare parts. Nothing worse than sitting a great boat dive because you don't have a spare fins strap. I keep my gear as simple and save as I can. I found over the years that quick release, buckles and all kinds of parts on gear you multiply the chance that something will break.
 

Back
Top Bottom