Video of Scuba Divers Getting Capital Punishment at 90fsw. It's SHOCKING!!!

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

.... I'm sure whatever needs to be done to reconcile the situation can be achieved.

No DD posts/vid/pics about BHB would pretty much sum it up. I'm a local friend of DD also, but I don't hand him a cup of gasoline and say "toss this on it too ". He's a long time experienced diver and adds alot of color and detailed knowledge. I have fun with DD when we meet up at local events. But this is ScubaBoard with a full spectrum of views and many of us have learned that no matter how badly you want to reply to a post,,,,,we just don't.. That's why I don't post fish pictures here, save it for FB. ScubaBoard just isn't the best venue for it.
 
The good news is, the latest reports I've read the past couple years state many of our highly targeted species are coming back to sustainable levels. Let's hope we continue down this path. But we really need to start focusing on pollution. A lot of fishermen don't care much about the small life... coral, crustaceans, etc. Well, they better, that's where and what the fish they seek live and eat.
Best way to piss off old fishermen (you know the ones, they say "you should have been here in the 70's") is to close an area. Best way to please a younger fisherman (you know the kind, you are one) is to close a spawning ground, the very place the old guys saw the same thousands of fish.

I did a lot of wok at Riley's hump. In 1999, the year before the closure, we saw exactly one mutton snapper. One. In 2006 we saw some 3 or schools of 3500 each, which is a spawning aggregation, and filmed spawning for the first time ever in the USA of that species. In 2009 we observed a spawning aggregation of Cubera, all a meter or more in length. The camera was turned off, but it was seen by a dive team of 4 on rebreathers. Now, Muttons are crowding the blacks out for room, luckily they don't spawn at the same time, so that isn't an issue.

What does this all mean? Well, for one the bite in the Tortugas is phenomenal. The headboat Yankee Capts hasn't missed a boat or person limit in about 2 years. Those fish are moving east. The spawning population at Western Dry Rocks is slowly increasing, except NOAA hasn't seen fit to close the area during spawning, so the Cuban fishermen still target the area during the full moons in April, May and June. But even with the old guys holding off closure of Western Dry Rocks, I have places I can go and shoot a legal Mutton any time I want.

That wasn't true when I moved here in 99.

If anyone wants scientific data, I can forward the links.
 
Best way to piss off old fishermen (you know the ones, they say "you should have been here in the 70's") is to close an area. Best way to please a younger fisherman (you know the kind, you are one) is to close a spawning ground, the very place the old guys saw the same thousands of fish.

I did a lot of wok at Riley's hump. In 1999, the year before the closure, we saw exactly one mutton snapper. One. In 2006 we saw some 3 or schools of 3500 each, which is a spawning aggregation, and filmed spawning for the first time ever in the USA of that species. In 2009 we observed a spawning aggregation of Cubera, all a meter or more in length. The camera was turned off, but it was seen by a dive team of 4 on rebreathers. Now, Muttons are crowding the blacks out for room, luckily they don't spawn at the same time, so that isn't an issue.

What does this all mean? Well, for one the bite in the Tortugas is phenomenal. The headboat Yankee Capts hasn't missed a boat or person limit in about 2 years. Those fish are moving east. The spawning population at Western Dry Rocks is slowly increasing, except NOAA hasn't seen fit to close the area during spawning, so the Cuban fishermen still target the area during the full moons in April, May and June. But even with the old guys holding off closure of Western Dry Rocks, I have places I can go and shoot a legal Mutton any time I want.

That wasn't true when I moved here in 99.

If anyone wants scientific data, I can forward the links.

Nice post, Frank. I saw this same thing diving in the Marine Park at Cano Island in Costa Rica. The amount of fish was jaw dropping. I am totally supportive of turning certain areas, spawning sites, etc. into protected areas. Let those areas replenish others and make sure the species we are targeting are at the age they need to be to reproduce.
 
@CuzzA

I certainly agree with your previous post--International, national and state laws and local ordinances are lacking or if in effect have little or no enforcement.

I first became aware of the devastating effects of pollution at a party attended by Dr. Bruce Hallstead, *. in the late 1950s who had just returned from Mimimata (S) Japan. It was a social gathering but was morphed into a learning experience on the effects of pollution caused by the Chizzo company and mercury into the water supply--( suggest that you google for information}

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
A little more history from a contest which was held in Southern California in 1956 -63 years ago
~~~ Where spearfishing began so many decades ago

Subject: Divers VS Pole fishermen - Water World magazine 1956- Bill Barada From my deep dusty files-- never published
(Water World - short lived 1950s California Diving publication owned by Bob Peterson )
Bill Barada -- Pioneer 1930s diver - organizer of the contest

Divers, Anglers & spin fishermen contest
A little history of the event ........

"A Unique Contest" ~~ Divers , Anglers and Spin fishermen
hold a three way contest ~~

Water World magazine (Source of the information)
July -August 1956
Pages 38-39 & 44

RULES:

10 participants plus 2 alternates
2 weapons (spear guns or Rods & reels per person
7 Varieties of fish

Only top 5 fish counted for total points
* WSB, YT & BFT = 1 point per pound
* BSB = 1 point per 5 pounds
* Berries & Kelp Bass =3 points per pound
* Sheepshead = 2 points per 3 pounds

BOAT:
"Fisherman 1" - Owned by Eddie Mc Ewen

LOCATION
Catalina Island

* Six different locations

* Six different conditions; darkness, rough water, kelp, sandy bottom, blue water, cove.


DIVER PARTICIPANTS: (As Identified in article)
* Homer Lockwood- President of LACD, Landed a 75 + pound halibut a year later but never registered it- Very active in SoCal diving-Internationally recognized for his work with the Sari Indians on Isla Tiberon,Mexico
* John Backus - unknown ???
* Doc Schrieber- unknown ???
* Woody Dimmel - well known in LA area..a spearfisherman of note..owned early dive shop.
* Bill Barada..Organizer of divers and Co origanizer of the contest

FYI ... A little about Bill Barada... .also a long time Orange County, California resident, social friend, fellow LA Co UW instructor, & NAUI Instructor #A 1, occasional dive buddy and minor mentor...)

"Bill Barada was not just a diving pioneer but one of our sport's Renaissance men, someone who had not one talent but many, who had not one career but several. He was an *spearfisherman,**inventor, writer, photographer, businessman, fireman and salesman - among other things. He was also a dive travel pioneer.

Bill was born in St. Joseph, MO, and grew up in Santa Monica, CA. He started free diving in 1935, when the sport was called "goggle fishing." In 1940 he formed the Los Angeles Neptunes, one of the first skin diving clubs in America.(from which all other Neptunes clubs were formed--LB Neptunes is still going strong today.- My Son Sam IV and I are inactive members )

In 1950, skin diving was threatened with restrictive legislation. To combat it, Barada founded the California Council of Diving Clubs, (CCDC) the first of its kind in the nation and probably the world. He also served as one of its presidents. (Bob Retherford was 3d President See www.portagequaarry.com Legends of diving -Sea Sabers Signaling system)

Bill was on the Board of Governors of the Underwater Society of America during its formative stages. He was active in legislation, conservation and safety issues throughout the country in scuba diving's early years and that interest never waned.

Since little equipment was available for early divers, Bill designed his own, forming The Bel-Aqua Water Sports Company * to produce and market it. His designs included the Bel-Aqua drysuit, an all-rubber snorkel and a CO2 speargun**. He owned and managed Bel-Aqua for seven years

(* See Exposure suits Part 11, Dry Suits,SW Diving news, June 1996, By Dr SDM page unknown- Bill made the first recreational Dry Suit)

(**see The Magnificient Gas Gun, Discover Diving, Jan/Feb 1993, pages 59-60 By Dr SDM- Bill invented the CO2 gas gun)

(** See Ode to a spear gun, Dive Bubbles (my TPR news paper column), Nov 5, 1999, By Dr SDM)

(** See A journey into the history of spearguns, Dive Bubbles (my news paper column), Several issues, 1999, By Dr SDM)

(*** See Powerheads and Bang sticks, google title, SDM- Bill marketed the Thunderhead Power head)

(*** See No easy answer ti shark threat, Dive Bubbles (my news paper column), Oct.12, 2001, By Dr SDM)

(*** See The Bang Stick, Dive Bubbles (my news paper column), Oct.19, 2001, By Dr SDM)

All of the above mention Bill Barada and or his products--and there is considerable more in other articles by other authors.

Bill was a fireman with the Los Angeles Fire Department from 1940 until his retirement in 1962; then he served as advertising and promotion manager of U.S. Divers (now known as Aqua-Lung).

He joined the staff of Skin Diver Magazine as sales promotion manager in 1963 He became marketing manager not long after, then "retired" - again - in 1968 Before, during and for many years after he was a Skin Diver staffer, Bill wrote articles on a variety of subjects. He teamed up with Dewey Bergman, founder of the first dive travel agency, Sea & See. The two were responsible for popularizing dive travel to Mexico and Tahiti.

In the spring of 1968, Bill left his full time position with Skin Diver to become its Special Assignments Editor. He and his first wife, Harriet, set out on a 20,000 mile journey in their Dodge station wagon, pulling a 24 foot Fireball tandem-wheeled house trailer. They traveled from California to Canada and eventually ended up in Florida. Along the way, Bill explored America's popular diving areas and visited with local dive shops, clubs and councils. He wrote articles about his experiences for Skin Diver. Readers could track his progress through the country by reading his monthly reports in 1968-69.

Bills first of many books, "Underwater," was published by Skin Diver's owner, Petersen Publishing, in 1955. He wrote several other books, including "Mask and Flippers," an as- told-to-book featuring Lloyd Bridges and "Spearfishing Where and how" for Voit (JBL). He wrote many TV scripts for Sea Hunt and a chapter in a National Geographic book, World Beneath the Sea. He was still writing articles in 1981 but when he stopped smoking the articles stopped coming in. It seems Bill could only write when he smoked. he stopped smoking after his marriage to Ellen and stopped writing

Besides his 1967 NOGI Award for the Arts, Bill received the Florida Governor's Award for Conservation and Communication in 1976. He lived with his second wife, Ellen, in Kissimmee, FL, until her death in 1997, when he moved to Orlando.

After Bill died on October 1, 1998, his ashes were brought to California and scattered off Pt. Fermin. He is once again among the creatures and the sea he loved so well and fought so hard to protect. "
Now you know a little about my friend Bill Barada

Back to the contest...

RESULTS

Spinners First place
Plungers: Close second

Spearfishermen: Distant third --Total points about half of the first place team--but Homer Lockwood was honored with the largest fish of the contest a 14 pound sheepshead, Woody Dimmel landed second largest a 13 pound sheepshead.

Conclusions;
This contest proved (?)....
* Pole fishermen take more fish than Spear fishermen
* Spear fishermen take larger fish than pole fishermen
* Pole fishermen catch fish with divers close by in water
* Fish are unaffected by spearfishermen in the water
* Pole fishermen can catch fish in all conditions-darkness, rough water etc - spearfishermen need ideal conditions

Bill Barada's final quote

"As in any sport, with any group of sportsmen, application of simple rules of courtesy and consideration allowed enthusiasts of these three different methods of fishing to enjoy each others company..."
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Spear fishing is selective fishing - Not wanton whole sale slaughter of every finned creature on a reef -
remember :

Spearfish with great dignity and pride in this the noblest of all man's activities, but with restraint and selective spearfishing rather than wholesale slaughter, for with every activity there is a Beginning; a Middle; and an End.........…"

And you entered spearfishing some where near the end...save something for future generations
Selective spearfishing is the answer

Dr. Sam Miller, III

* The monumental work of Dr Bruce Halstead " Poisonous and venomous Marine Animals of the world" (LCCC 65-60000) a three volume book set published in 1965

Volume 1 is 994 Pages, Volume 11 consists of 1070 pages and volume 111 consists of 1006 pages for total of 3007 well illustrated pages jammed packed with valuable information. Each 8 -1/2 X 11 page is lavishly illustrated with drawings and underwater and topside photographs of the animals .
Yes I have a set each personally inscribed to me

SDM,III
 
https://www.shearwater.com/products/teric/

Back
Top Bottom