I've questioned staying at an AI too given the restaurants available on the island, but I spend too much when I do it a la carte and found that the Palace restaurants impressed me enough to stay in. However, if I were to eat out a few nights, there are three places I'd hit: (1) La Cocay, for upscale Caribbean - I went soon after they opened, over 10 years ago, and they're still around so that's a good sign; (2) El Moro, for excellent Mexican at excellent prices, but a bit out of the way; and (3) Prima for Italian/Continental - I've only dined at the old location (4 times, the last was with a friend of the owner so we got a great table and were sent right up notwithstanding the hour+ wait), but have heard the new location is amazing.
Unfortunately the Palace only has 4 dining options, plus we're probably going to use up our credits for the "romantic dinner for 2" twice (prime beef, lobster, Moet - they normally price it at $350/couple) and that's our six night's dinners accounted for. That's fine by me since by my calculations the Palace is only a great deal if you don't eat out. On our last trip, we dropped $50 for drinks/snacks during our meet and greet and, while the conversation was great and the food and drinks were just fine, I almost felt like I was "wasting" the money since we could have had our fill for free at the Palace.
As I'm already tentatively planning our next trip to the island, at least in my day dreams, our next time we'll probably go a la carte since there are so many new places to try since the last time I dined around. This trip is mainly for some R&R and not having to worry about where to eat makes it even more relaxing IMO. Our last two trips involved touring ourselves around Italy. We had a great time, but it was a lot of work figuring out where to eat each night on top of making our way around sightseeing all day. This trip, I just wanted to park myself somewhere exceedingly comfortable so my brain can hibernate for (almost) a week and I'm confident the Palace will serve that purpose admirably.
We leave for the airport in exactly 24 hours and 15 minutes and I am getting excited.