The topic is Egypt getting a bad rap when it comes to LOBs. The initial poster talks about 4 LOBs that he says are safe. That doesn't make all LOBs safe, and it doesn't necessarily make the ones he named safe. What if by some remote chance something bad happens, and his boat needs to be rescued?? The Egyptian Navy doesn't have rescue divers and prevented other rescue divers from working for some time in the Sea Story tragedy. The Egyptian government forced survivors to sign statements in Arabic and refused to let people leave if they didn't. They never did an adequate investigation and they don't have adequate safety standards. That's enough for me to say , NO , they aren't getting a bad rap, they deserve the horrible reputation they have.
Yes, go dive Egypt, but not from a LOB, dive from the shore or of a day boat.